Abstract:Background: Pay-for-performance initiatives have been suggested as a way to improve the quality of patient care and provide incentives to improve providers' performance. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has endorsed such programs to improve quality of care. Objective: To examine the state of quality initiatives endorsed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services in which institutions, provider groups, and physicians are awarded incentives based on adherence to composite metrics. Method: A literature search was conducted using the keywords "pay-for-performance," "quality improvement," "medical errors," and "physician incentive plans." Results: Although quality of care has improved in healthcare settings that engage in pay-for-performance initiatives, what can be attributed to payer-incentive programs is uncertain. Studies demonstrate that, of the 25 hospitals classified by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to be in the lowest decile of quality improvements, all still made significant progress in adhering to quality metrics after participation in the study. Financial rewards, however, were distributed based on a predetermined threshold established by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to be given only to participants who fell in the top 2 deciles. Penalties were incurred by the 51 hospitals that were within the bottom 2 deciles despite making substantial improvements. At such institutions, large minority communities and Medicaid populations comprise the patient populations. Other pay-for-performance schemes, such as employer-based purchasing, consumer health-spending accounts, and collaborative groups, were studied, with little data to support definite benefits. Conclusions: Examining rates of improvement in adherence to pay-for-performance initiatives when determining how to distribute financial rewards should be studied alongside the current classification by absolute deciles. By rewarding rates of improvement, potential elimination of quality disparities for hospitals that serve large Medicaid and minority populations can be achieved, because such organizations are encouraged to invest in quality improvement as a result of substantial progress made. Although alternative strategies like employer-driven value-based purchasing and collaboratives seem promising, the long-term effects of such initiatives still need to be studied. Creating greater financial incentives for individual providers to participate in pay-for-performance programs for many years to come will remain a challenge.

Influencing physician practice patterns

Hospitals' marketing challenge: influencing physician behavior

High and Rising Health Care Costs. Part 4: Can Costs Be Controlled While Preserving Quality?

Contemporary organizational strategies for enhancing value in health care

Using Behavioral Economics to Design Physician Incentives That Deliver High-Value Care

Doctors as Resource Stewards? Translating High-Value, Cost-Conscious Care to the Consulting Room

Factors Influencing Physician Practices' Adoption of Behavioral Health Integration in the United States: A Qualitative Study

Pay-for-Performance Initiatives: Modest Benefits for Improving Healthcare Quality

Engaging doctors in the health care revolution

Relationship Between Physician Financial Incentives and Clinical Pathway Compliance: a Cross-Sectional Study of 18 Public Hospitals in China

Hospitals' strategies to reduce costs and improve quality: survey of hospital leaders

Triadic Relationships in Healthcare

A Path to Risk: Critical Elements of a Structured Approach

Strategy and risk sharing in hospital-postacute care integration

The efficient delivery of elective orthopedic care

Consumer product branding strategy and the marketing of physicians' services

Financial and clinical performance: bridging the gap

Championship Management for Healthcare Organizations

Performance management in small practices

Trends in acquisitions of physician practices and subsequent clinical integration: A mixed methods study

Patient-centric care management