Genome evolution and divergence in cis- regulatory architecture is associated with condition-responsive development in horned dung beetles

Phillip L Davidson,Armin P Moczek,Phillip L. Davidson,Armin P. Moczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1011165

IF: 4.5

2024-03-06

PLoS Genetics

Abstract:Phenotypic plasticity is thought to be an important driver of diversification and adaptation to environmental variation, yet the genomic mechanisms mediating plastic trait development and evolution remain poorly understood. The Scarabaeinae, or true dung beetles, are a species-rich clade of insects recognized for their highly diversified nutrition-responsive development including that of cephalic horns—evolutionarily novel, secondary sexual weapons that exhibit remarkable intra- and interspecific variation. Here, we investigate the evolutionary basis for horns as well as other key dung beetle traits via comparative genomic and developmental assays. We begin by presenting chromosome-level genome assemblies of three dung beetle species in the tribe Onthophagini (> 2500 extant species) including Onthophagus taurus , O . sagittarius , and Digitonthophagus gazella . Comparing these assemblies to those of seven other species across the order Coleoptera identifies evolutionary changes in coding sequence associated with metabolic regulation of plasticity and metamorphosis. We then contrast chromatin accessibility in developing head horn tissues of high- and low-nutrition O . taurus males and females and identify distinct cis -regulatory architectures underlying nutrition- compared to sex-responsive development, including a large proportion of recently evolved regulatory elements sensitive to horn morph determination. Binding motifs of known and new candidate transcription factors are enriched in these nutrition-responsive open chromatin regions. Our work highlights the importance of chromatin state regulation in mediating the development and evolution of plastic traits, demonstrates gene networks are highly evolvable transducers of environmental and genetic signals, and provides new reference-quality genomes for three species that will bolster future developmental, ecological, and evolutionary studies of this insect group. Phenotypic plasticity is the ability of a single genotype to produce multiple phenotypes in response to environmental variation and thus represents an important evolutionary mechanism for organismal adaptation and diversification. In this study, we investigate the genomic basis for phenotypic plasticity in Onthophagini horned dung beetles, a highly diverse (~2500 species) tribe of beetles renowned for their developmental plasticity. We assemble and annotate chromosome-level genome assembles for three Onthophagini species and identify examples of gene family and coding sequence evolution potentially associated with nutrition-responsiveness in this insect group. When then compare chromatin conformation underlying head horn development and specification in Onthophagus taurus , a species with dramatic nutrition- and sex-based differences in horn shape. We find chromatin accessibility likely plays a critical role in specifying nutritional and sexual horn dimorphisms in this species. Further, we show nutrition- and sex-responsive horn development are controlled by largely distinct, rather than shared, regulatory architectures, and the acquisition of lineage-specific regulatory elements may have played an outsized role in the evolution of nutrition-responsive development of this trait. Our results highlight the significance of chromatin accessibility and regulatory element activity in the regulation of plastic phenotypes and the highly-evolvable nature of developmental gene networks.

genetics & heredity