How I fuse Western science with Traditional Knowledge

Virginia Gewin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-00018-7

IF: 64.8

2024-01-09

Nature

Abstract:Indigenous Canadian ecologist Jennifer Grenz abandons colonial restoration dogma to reshape land systems according to community needs. Indigenous Canadian ecologist Jennifer Grenz abandons colonial restoration dogma to reshape land systems according to community needs.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Ecological research 'in a good way' means ethical and equitable relationships with Indigenous Peoples and Lands

Andrea J. Reid,Deborah A. McGregor,Allyson K. Menzies,Lauren E. Eckert,Catherine M. Febria,Jesse N. Popp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41559-023-02309-0

IF: 19.1

2024-01-16

Nature Ecology & Evolution

Abstract:The current and fervent uptick in the natural sciences of seeking to engage with Indigenous partners signals a change in attitudes towards Indigenous knowledge systems and Peoples as well as their rights, but comes with a substantial amount of risk, burden and peril. To aid scientists in conducting research 'in a good way', we offer key insights and guidance that are rooted in our own scientific training and communities of practice.

ecology,evolutionary biology
Indigenous Feminisms: Disturbing Colonialism in Environmental Science Partnerships

Carla M. Dhillon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2332649220908608

2020-02-27

Sociology of Race and Ethnicity

Abstract:Efforts have been under way by Indigenous peoples to reanimate governance that includes people of all ages and genders. Simultaneous initiatives to decolonize science within environmental fields must confront how settler colonial systems can continue to operate under the guise of partnership. Indigenous feminist theories aid understanding of ongoing colonialism alongside heteropatriarchy and racism with attempts to dismantle oppression in everyday practice. The author examines governance in a North American environmental science partnership consisting of Indigenous and non-Indigenous climate scientists. Using a mixed-methods social network approach, the author evaluates central actors in the national-scale climate science organization on the basis of intersectional identities, relational ties, and structural leadership roles. Findings indicate that Indigenous women and youth were not among core governance dominated by elder Indigenous men and White women. However, Indigenous women consistently bridged distant members back into the group and provided less visible labor to support the organization. These did not translate to decision-making roles. The author argues that Indigenous values of relational reciprocity and self-determination need to supersede the rhetoric of diversity in environmental fields. The case demonstrates the importance of inclusive Indigenous governance to decolonize environmental partnerships and the potential lack of legitimacy should unexamined notions of tradition be used to obscure settler colonial dominance.

sociology,ethnic studies
Science Must Embrace Traditional and Indigenous Knowledge to Solve Our Biodiversity Crisis

Edwin Ogar,Gretta Pecl,Tero Mustonen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2020.07.006

IF: 14.944

2020-08-01

One Earth

Abstract:Traditional and Indigenous knowledge has successfully preserved and restored biodiversity across the globe. However, its recognition as being as equally valid as Western science as a way of knowing remains lacking. If we are to preserve global biodiversity and rewild key habitats, science and Indigenous knowledge must work in partnership while also being restitutive and rights based.
Right fire for right Country: Integrating First Nations knowledge and Western science in land management

Elle Bowd,David Lindenmayer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/emr.12593

2024-01-14

Ecological Management & Restoration

Abstract:Ecological Management &Restoration, Volume 24, Issue 2-3, Page 156-158, May-September 2023.

ecology
Indigenous land-based practices for climate crisis adaptions

Ranjan Datta,Jebunnessa Chapola,Kara Owen,Margot Hurlbert,Audra Foggin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.explore.2024.103042

2024-08-20

Abstract:Indigenous communities across Canada persist at the forefront of environmental and climate-related challenges, necessitating a concerted effort to integrate traditional Indigenous land-based knowledge and practices that inherently promote environmental protection and resilience. Using a decolonial feminist theoretical framework, this research centers on Indigenous community perspectives on the climate crisis and their land-based adaptions. Such an approach empowers Indigenous communities to reclaim agency over their narratives and shape research agendas congruent with their lived realities and aspirations. The study concludes by promoting the imperative of revitalizing traditional Indigenous land-based knowledge, practices and relationships with their ancestral lands. Despite emerging recognition within the scientific literature and international agreements, such as the Paris Agreement, of the significance of traditional Indigenous land-based knowledge, many climate mitigation and adaptation initiatives continue to overlook Indigenous participation at various decision-making junctures. Hence, this paper advocates the necessity for international frameworks to acknowledge and integrate traditional knowledge systems and Indigenous participation across national borders, fostering inclusive climate crisis solutions that resonate with Indigenous communities' perspectives and experiences.
Reconciliation and Relationality in Water Research and Management in Canada: Implementing Indigenous Ontologies, Epistemologies, and Methodologies

Heather Castleden,Catherine Hart,Ashlee Cunsolo,Sherilee Harper,Debbie Martin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-42806-2_5

2016-11-01

Abstract:Water-related issues disproportionately affect Indigenous communities in Canada. Despite millions in investment, Western-trained scientists, engineers, and other researchers as well as the government agencies that have constitutionally-mandated fiduciary responsibilities to address such issues have been rather unsuccessful in solving them. This has been due, in large part, to an overreliance on methods of Western science and management, ignoring the vast place-based wisdom of Indigenous knowledge systems and relational practices regarding water found across the country. The underlying reasons for this partiality are not innocuous; entrenched colonial and racist policies, programs, and practices have persisted across time and space. In recent years, there is increasing recognition of the importance of applying Indigenous approaches to water challenges in Canada. But strategies for successful implementation are only beginning to emerge. In an attempt to respond to this knowledge gap, our research has sought to systematically identify and assess how both Indigenous and Western ontologies, epistemologies, and methodologies have been implemented in water research and management. In doing so, this chapter identifies some of the most promising practices in Canada. We share these with the goal of contributing to processes of reconciliation and responsibility towards each other as well as our roles as water stewards across the country.
Learning with Lakota scientists

H Holden Thorp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.ads7901

IF: 56.9

2024-09-06

Science

Abstract:In her bestselling book Braiding Sweetgrass, Robin Wall Kimmerer describes the reciprocity between humans and nature while also contemplating another potentially beneficial relationship-between Indigenous knowledge and Western science. Not surprisingly, this integration is easier said than done. Recently, for example, the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) terminated a $2 million study on how to best combine Indigenous and Western approaches to understanding the natural world. The problem? As Kimmerer herself said on this page, effective collaboration with Indigenous communities requires Western science to respect cultural practices and scientific ideas that diverge from the reductionist approach. Unless the scientific community leans into this discomfort, we will never unlock the possibility that this relationship could help address some of society's most distressing problems.
Studying Across: Anthropology, Conflict Transformation and Cultural Violence in Environmental Conflict

Brenda J. Fitzpatrick

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1590/1809-43412021v18a704

2021-01-01

Abstract:Abstract Using the example of the controversial Site C dam in British Columbia, Canada, this article describes how ethnographic research that incorporated a conflict transformation perspective and included individuals from both sides of the issue highlighted both contrasting views on human-environment relations and the inequitable conditions under which they met through the Environmental Assessment process. The article argues that an anthropological approach that incorporates a conflict transformation perspective is particularly well-suited to identify, and potentially to address, the “discourses, narratives, and worldviews” (Rodriguez and Inturias 2018: 96) that operate as “cultural violence” (Galtung, 1990) in state-Indigenous environmental conflicts, legitimating structural and environmental violence.
“Gardening in Eden”: Wasted Lives, or Detoxic Identities in Gail AndersonDargatz’s Turtle Valley and Barbara Kingsolver’s Prodigal Summer

Pedro Miguel Carmona Rodríguez,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25145/j.recaesin.2023.86.04

2023-01-01

Revista Canaria de Estudios Ingleses

Abstract:This paper analyzes the inflection of a border-crossing ecological concern on the regional cultures of settlement through Gail Anderson-Dargatz’s Turtle Valley (2007) and Barbara Kingsolver’s Prodigal Summer (2000). Their engagement with the contingent position of the farmers in the British Columbia Shuswap region, and the southern Appalachian Zebulon County resituates the self. The struggle for production is substituted by a revisionist attitude that relocates (wo)men and nature in a sustainable coexistence that approaches the human species and others. The ecological awareness of these novels uses a postindustrial landscape where human bodies and lives exhibit the malaise inflicted on the environment; they increasingly become waste(d) and toxic, and their habitat becomes a threat, also materialized in (post)natural catastrophes impelling the relocation of human communities, or business reinvention. The human wastification of Eden is instrumental to launch a revision that detoxifies identity thanks to a remodeled bond with nature.
Into the wild: uncertain frontiers and sustainable human-nature interactions

Jennifer Patterson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fsoc.2024.1325963

2024-03-19

Abstract:Humans seldom consider themselves as animals, and that humans are animals is a truth frequently turned into an insulting metaphor indicating "uncivilized" behavior in many cultures. Interestingly, the "civilizing" aspects of Western Culture in the Global North are historically derived from traditions of democracy based on living in cities from which the wild has been banished. This is embedded in the English language since civilizing and civilization come from the Latin for city, civitas, the place where citizens hold voting rights. Beyond the gates of civilization is the wild. How the wild and nature have been constructed and demarcated is an enormously complex and enduring challenge in western philosophy as it relates to knowledge-making, existence, truth, and reality. Indeed, whilst people generally believe they know what nature means, they rarely realize that little in nature is wild. Furthermore, the concept of uncertainty, central to the pandemic, is compounded by climate instability and a potentially disastrous future. This is breaking down what is known, requiring porous and flexible conceptual frontiers and a transdisciplinary approach. This article traces the linguistic separation of humans from their animal origins and wilder environments for political and increasingly greedy economic purposes. It explores the acknowledged complexity of healthy human-nature interactions, juxtaposing information mainly from the humanities and social sciences. Demonstrating how unhealthy the current paradigm has proven to be for humans and the natural world, it brings together conflicting information to disrupt traditional certainties using an innovative bricolage methodology. It weaves and combines different ways of knowing as it considers forms of knowledge-making, rewilding, foraging, the place of magical thinking, and vital force. It concludes that a new paradigm is needed to enable a way of working toward any vision of healthy human-nature interaction.
Knowledge, Spirit, Reason: An Essay in Comparative Philosophy

Ian Angus

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02722011.2021.1942941

2021-07-03

American Review of Canadian Studies

Abstract:One of the ways in which a philosophy may exhibit its national character is to take up an acknowledged national theme or project and address it philosophically. This is the approach that I will take. This article establishes, through reference to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (2008–2015) and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007), that the relationship between Indigenous knowledge and Western science-based knowledge has become a recognized public issue in Canada. It shows that a relationship, or translation, exists between Indigenous knowledge and Western science-based knowledge through a linchpin that can be called "ecology." Finally, it explicates the relation of spirit to embodiment within this translation through a comparison of Indigenous knowledge with a contemporary current in cognitive science.
Indigenous ways to go to school: Exploring many visions

Arlene Stairs

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01434632.1994.9994557

1994-01-01

Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development

Abstract:Indigenous schools are sites of negotiation between cultures in contact, and evidence cultural creativity in an unpredictable diversity of educational designs which defy accepted theoretical and methodological packages. Among other world contexts, Canadian Inuit and Mohawk situations illustrate this meeting of formal and traditional educational models, and suggest the dangers in oversimplified ‘learning style’ dichotomies. The meeting of formal and traditional learning and teaching is very significantly played out in the evolution of new and complementary language forms in indigenous schools. The western cultural package of standard literacy practice, schooling, and abstract thought is being opened up and challenged. As the focus expands from ‘what’ (content) to ‘how’ (process) and to ‘why’ (values and meaning), there is reason for optimism over the cultural negotiation of indigenous education. Emerging ‘third cultural realities’ offer paths to cultural survival beyond assimilation, isolation, or anomie.

linguistics
Embodying relationality through immersive sustainability solutions with Indigenous communities in the Ecuadorian Amazon

Antonia Polheim,David Manuel-Navarrete,Janna Goebel,Jacqueline Loos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11625-024-01523-4

IF: 6

2024-06-27

Sustainability Science

Abstract:The sustainability crisis is rooted in Western paradigms of separation. To overcome the challenges we face, Western-educated people, like us, must question our deeply internalized ontological assumptions and welcome alternative relational perspectives. Grasping a relational cosmovision, not only cognitively but embodying it physically and emotionally, can enable personal and social transformations that address the root causes of sustainability problems. We explore how relational forms of immersion in Kichwa and Waorani communities, through transformative and place-based learning experiences, may foster the embodiment of relationality. Students from a Western research institution participated in a two-week study-abroad program on Indigenous sustainability solutions in the Ecuadorian Amazon. Participant observation and interviews revealed how students built stronger and more relational connections to nature and questioned the universality of Western ontological assumptions. These transformative shifts were fostered through experiences of embodying relationality facilitated through opportunities of relating, reflecting, and embracing offered by the setting and the program's activities. Findings showcase how transformative experiences of embodying relationality can contribute to ontological shifts strengthening the relation with and to nature and constitute immersive sustainability solutions. We conclude with a dynamic model of the process through which Western-educated people trained in experiencing themselves as separate individuals realize and embody their embeddedness in the net of relationships with all beings.

environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology
Centering Indigenous Knowledges in ecology and beyond

Joseph Gazing Wolf,Danielle D Ignace,Dominique M David‐Chavez,Lydia L Jennings,Deondre Smiles,Paulette Blanchard,Ellen Simmons,Diana Doan‐Crider,Ruth Plenty Sweetgrass‐She Kills,Michelle Montgomery,Melissa K Nelson,Linda Black Elk,Luke Black Elk,Gwen Bridge,Ann Marie Chischilly,Kevin Deer,Kathy DeerinWater,Trudy Ecoffey,Judith Vergun,Daniel Wildcat,James Rattling Leaf

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/fee.2776

2024-06-20

Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment

Abstract:There is a resurgent enthusiasm for Indigenous Knowledges (IK) across settler–colonial institutions of research, education, and conservation. But like fitting a square peg in a round hole, IK are being forced into colonial systems, and then only as marginal alternatives. To address this mismatch, the Traditional Ecological Knowledge Section of the Ecological Society of America (ESA) hosted a 2‐day workshop—entitled Elevating Indigenous Knowledges in Ecology—at the 2022 ESA Annual Meeting, which was held on Kanien'keháka (Mohawk) and Ho‐de‐no‐sau‐nee‐ga (Haudenosaunee) territories in Montreal, Canada. This gathering of 21 interdisciplinary Indigenous ecologists included scholars from across the career and professional spectrum. By consensus, workshop participants (including the authors of this article) identified four emergent themes and respective guiding questions as a pathway toward the transformation of settler–colonial institutions into IK‐led spaces. We highlight this pathway to support actions toward systemic change, inspire future directions for Indigenous and non‐Indigenous ecologists, and nurture stronger relationships between Indigenous communities and the Western sciences, toward actualized decoloniality.

environmental sciences,ecology
[Indigenous peoples' ways of life and the environment: an ecofeminist authority assertion]

Hugo S Ramírez-García

DOI: https://doi.org/10.30444/CB.73

Abstract:What is the ecological value of the indigenous ways of life? For several years now, there has been a widespread conviction, at the institutional and academic levels, that indigenous or native ways of life are a resource for biodiversity conservation. In contrast to this idea, which leads to strategies with significant implicit dangers, this article defends the thesis that the way of life of the original peoples is a valuable experience that contributes to enhance the necessary wisdom to sustain those actions aimed to genuinely repair the current fracture between humanity and nature. With this in mind, the author explores ecofeminist proposals that offer grounds for acknowledging authority over experiences that have remained at the periphery of the modern mainstream: precisely those that are carried out by indigenous peoples.
Rethinking the maps: A case study of knowledge incorporation in Canadian wildfire risk management and planning

Jennifer Sherry,Timothy Neale,Tara K McGee,Maria Sharpe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2018.12.116

2019-03-15

Abstract:As the natural fire regimes of Canada's Boreal forests have been transformed by dynamic social, economic, ecological and political drivers, wildfires have become a locus of increasingly complex land management decisions. But while, in Canada and elsewhere, social researchers have examined communities at risk of experiencing wildfire, the agencies and practitioners responsible for wildfire management have thus far been underrepresented in empirical inquiry. This article presents a case study of wildfire management in northern Alberta, examining how different forms of knowledge and experiences were incorporated into the creation of a new plan to support decision-making. Findings from interviews and a workshop confirm that 'science' in such applied contexts is not a pure entity. Instead, the objects represented internally and externally as 'scientific' have necessarily been shaped by the values and priorities of the individuals and institutions that have constructed them. Further, this case study revealed social factors that support the maintenance of institutional status quos, such as the commitment to total wildfire suppression policy, despite broad agreement amongst participants about superior alternatives. These findings support the need for further research on wildfire management agencies, and suggest that progress in wildfire management may be limited by mismatched expectations of 'good' policy between stakeholder groups and by practitioners' conceptions of their own institutional identity.
Creating cultural refugia to transform the boundaries of science

Marijke Hecht

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11422-020-10010-y

Abstract:This paper is a reflection on Bobby Habig, Preeti Gupta, and Jennifer Adams' article Disrupting deficit narratives in informal science education: Amplifying community cultural wealth theory to youth learning and engagement. The article examines the significance of community cultural capital and the need for informal STEM institutions to engage more deliberately with the knowledge and lived experiences that youth bring to programs they participate in. In my response, I question whether the informal science institution of study had changed in response to these young people. As a 'science insider,' I explore how research experiences in informal science education institutions such as museums are tightly bounded by and connected with ancient European scientific practices that limit a deep embrace of community cultural wealth. If the aim is for youth to develop their science identities, then these informal science education institutions need to question what kind of science people they are asking youth to become. I consider how informal science education institutions might remake themselves as cultural refugia, where interrogation of the dominant Eurocentric norms of what science is can be challenged and transformed.
How I apply Indigenous wisdom to Western science and nurture Native American students

Robin Donovan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-03114-w

IF: 64.8

2024-09-26

Nature

Abstract:Joslynn Lee's Indigenous heritage shapes her research and how she mentors the next generation of biochemists. Joslynn Lee's Indigenous heritage shapes her research and how she mentors the next generation of biochemists.

multidisciplinary sciences
Knowledge versus Education in the Margins: An Indigenous and Feminist Critique of Education

Anna Lydia Svalastog,Shawn Wilson,Ketil Lenert Hansen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci11100627

2021-10-11

Education Sciences

Abstract:This article highlights the perceptions and expectations of knowledge that many people, including educators and policy makers, take for granted. Our focus of understanding is Indigenous studies and gender studies. Our aim is to show how modern education undermines these fields of studies. We use an autoethnographic method, reflecting more than 75 years as pupils/students and more than 90 years as educators. We have carefully chosen narratives of exposure to knowledge outside the educational system, as well as narratives of limitations posed upon us by the educational system. This narrative approach makes it possible for us to investigate and discuss our grief about areas of knowledge that society cries for, but the educational system continuously finds ways to resist. Our conclusion is that crucial knowledge is located outside the educational system, where individuals, groups, and communities cherish, protect, and guard knowledge that the educational system marginalises or excludes. As this knowledge is fundamental for life, our message is that the educational system needs to re-evaluate its strategies to stay relevant.
Ecology: The fruits of local knowledge

Kate L Wootton,Phil O'B Lyver,Kate L. Wootton,Phil O’B. Lyver

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2024.02.054

IF: 9.2

2024-04-09

Current Biology

Abstract:Local and indigenous communities often have an intimate connection to nature that is reflected in their ecological knowledge and practices. A new study shows that local ecological knowledge can transform the scientific understanding of an ecological network.

cell biology,biochemistry & molecular biology,biology

How I fuse Western science with Traditional Knowledge

Ecological research 'in a good way' means ethical and equitable relationships with Indigenous Peoples and Lands

Indigenous Feminisms: Disturbing Colonialism in Environmental Science Partnerships

Science Must Embrace Traditional and Indigenous Knowledge to Solve Our Biodiversity Crisis

Right fire for right Country: Integrating First Nations knowledge and Western science in land management

Indigenous land-based practices for climate crisis adaptions

Reconciliation and Relationality in Water Research and Management in Canada: Implementing Indigenous Ontologies, Epistemologies, and Methodologies

Learning with Lakota scientists

Studying Across: Anthropology, Conflict Transformation and Cultural Violence in Environmental Conflict

“Gardening in Eden”: Wasted Lives, or Detoxic Identities in Gail AndersonDargatz’s Turtle Valley and Barbara Kingsolver’s Prodigal Summer

Into the wild: uncertain frontiers and sustainable human-nature interactions

Knowledge, Spirit, Reason: An Essay in Comparative Philosophy

Indigenous ways to go to school: Exploring many visions

Embodying relationality through immersive sustainability solutions with Indigenous communities in the Ecuadorian Amazon

Centering Indigenous Knowledges in ecology and beyond

[Indigenous peoples' ways of life and the environment: an ecofeminist authority assertion]

Rethinking the maps: A case study of knowledge incorporation in Canadian wildfire risk management and planning

Creating cultural refugia to transform the boundaries of science

How I apply Indigenous wisdom to Western science and nurture Native American students

Knowledge versus Education in the Margins: An Indigenous and Feminist Critique of Education

Ecology: The fruits of local knowledge