Comparing multiple infection control measures in a nursing home setting: a simulation study
Haomin Li,Daniel K Sewell,Ted Herman,Sriram V Pemmeraju,Alberto M Segre,Aaron C Miller,Philip M Polgreen,Daniel K. Sewell,Sriram V. Pemmeraju,Alberto M. Segre,Aaron C. Miller,Philip M. Polgreen,for the CDC MInD-Healthcare Group
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/ice.2024.43
2024-03-16
Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology
Abstract:Objective: Compare the effectiveness of multiple mitigation measures designed to protect nursing home residents from infectious disease outbreaks. Design: Agent-based simulation study. Setting: Simulation environment of a small nursing home. Methods: We collected temporally detailed and spatially fine-grained location information from nursing home healthcare workers (HCWs) using sensor motes. We used these data to power an agent-based simulation of a COVID-19 outbreak using realistic time-varying estimates of infectivity and diagnostic sensitivity. Under varying community prevalence and transmissibility, we compared the mitigating effects of (i) regular screening and isolation, (ii) inter-resident contact restrictions, (iii) reduced HCW presenteeism, and (iv) modified HCW scheduling. Results: Across all configurations tested, screening every other day and isolating positive cases decreased the attack rate by an average of 27% to 0.501 on average, while contact restrictions decreased the attack rate by an average of 35%, resulting in an attack rate of only 0.240, approximately half that of screening/isolation. Combining both interventions impressively produced an attack rate of only 0.029. Halving the observed presenteeism rate led to an 18% decrease in the attack rate, but if combined with screening every 6 days, the effect of reducing presenteeism was negligible. Altering work schedules had negligible effects on the attack rate. Conclusions: Universal contact restrictions are highly effective for protecting vulnerable nursing home residents, yet adversely affect physical and mental health. In high transmission and/or high community prevalence situations, restricting inter-resident contact to groups of 4 was effective and made highly effective when paired with weekly testing.
infectious diseases,public, environmental & occupational health