Overqualified Employees' Actual Turnover: The Role of Growth Dissatisfaction and the Contextual Effects of Age and Pay

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10869-024-09959-2

IF: 6.604

2024-06-05

Journal of Business and Psychology

Abstract:Overqualified employees are those with more knowledge, skills, and abilities than their job requires. While these competent workers can bring benefits to firms, they also pose a high risk of turnover. However, the evidence is insufficient on whether, why, and when they actually leave and how organizations can manage their turnover effectively. Based on self-determination theory, we propose that unfulfilled internal aspirations for personal growth can be a major driving force of turnover among overqualified employees. Moreover, we explore how such a mechanism varies by employee's age and whether pay can exert a mitigating influence. Using longitudinal data over three years (from 2017 to 2019) with a large sample of workers ( N = 2473), we found an indirect effect where perceived overqualification reduces growth satisfaction, which in turn leads to actual turnover. Further, we found a three-way moderating effect of pay and age on the relationship between growth satisfaction and turnover, indicating that pay's effect of deterring turnover was stronger for older employees. This study has theoretical implications for a better understanding of overqualified employees' turnover driven by their internal impetus, as well as implications for pay policies that effectively manage overqualified workers in age-diverse modern organizations.

psychology, applied,business

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the actual turnover behavior of overqualified employees and the driving factors behind it. Specifically, the author explores the following aspects:

1. **Impact of Internal Growth Dissatisfaction**: Overqualified employees may feel a lack of personal growth opportunities due to their knowledge, skills, and abilities exceeding job requirements. The study examines whether this growth dissatisfaction leads to actual turnover.

2. **Moderating Role of Age and Compensation**: The author further investigates how employees' age and compensation influence the relationship between growth dissatisfaction and actual turnover. Specifically, whether compensation can mitigate the turnover tendency caused by growth dissatisfaction and whether this mitigating effect varies among employees of different age groups.

### Summary of Main Research Questions:
- **Why Overqualified Employees Leave**: Using Self-Determination Theory (SDT), the author proposes that unmet personal growth needs are the main driver of turnover among overqualified employees.
- **Role of Age**: Employees of different age groups have different growth needs, which affects their response to being overqualified.
- **Moderating Role of Compensation**: Whether compensation, as an external incentive, can offset the turnover tendency caused by growth dissatisfaction, and whether this moderating effect differs among employees of different age groups.

### Research Background and Motivation:
- **Prevalence of Overqualified Employees**: Approximately 20% of employees globally are considered overqualified. While these employees can bring diverse value to organizations, they also pose a higher turnover risk.
- **Limitations of Existing Theories**: Existing research mainly relies on Relative Deprivation Theory and Person-Job Fit Theory, which focus more on external factors and overlook the internal needs of overqualified employees.
- **New Theoretical Perspective**: By introducing Self-Determination Theory, the author emphasizes the importance of intrinsic needs (such as growth needs) and explores how these needs influence employee behavior.

### Research Methods and Data:
- **Longitudinal Data**: Using three-year longitudinal data from 2017 to 2019, with a sample size of 2473 employees.
- **Multi-Stage Model**: Analyzing the impact of perceived overqualification, growth satisfaction, age, and compensation on actual turnover through a multi-stage model.

### Research Contributions:
- **New Theoretical Perspective**: Explaining the turnover behavior of overqualified employees from the perspective of intrinsic needs, enriching the existing theoretical framework.
- **Heterogeneous Impact of Age**: Revealing the differences in responses to overqualification among employees of different age groups.
- **Moderating Role of Compensation**: Proposing the role of compensation as an external incentive in mitigating turnover caused by growth dissatisfaction, particularly more significant among older employees.

Through this research, the author hopes to provide organizations with effective management strategies to retain overqualified employees and reduce their turnover rate.