Problems and Opportunities in the use of Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis for Assessing Body Composition During Ketogenic Diets: A Scoping Review

Antonio Paoli,Francesco Campa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13679-024-00573-0

2024-05-29

Current Obesity Reports

Abstract:The use of bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) for monitoring body composition during the ketogenic diet has experienced a rapid surge. This scoping review aimed to assess the validity of procedures applying BIA in the ketogenic diet and to suggest best practices for optimizing its utilization.

endocrinology & metabolism,nutrition & dietetics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the application of bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) in assessing body composition during a ketogenic diet and proposes improvements.

### Research Objective
The purpose of this literature review is to evaluate the effectiveness of using BIA to monitor body composition during a ketogenic diet and to propose best practice methods for optimizing its application.

### Main Findings
- The authors conducted a systematic review of relevant literature, selecting 72 eligible studies for examination.
- Most of these studies used foot-to-hand or standing position techniques for BIA measurement.
- Only a few studies reported raw bioelectrical impedance parameters (such as resistance R, reactance Xc, and phase angle PhA).
- Most studies did not report the formulas used to predict body composition (such as fat mass FM, fat-free mass FFM, etc.), making it difficult to assess the validity of BIA outputs.
- The lack of raw data reporting also limits the reproducibility of methods in future research.

### Discussion and Recommendations
- The current application of BIA technology in ketogenic diet research has shortcomings, including insufficient description of equipment and techniques, lack of raw data reporting, and absence of predictive equations.
- To improve the effectiveness of BIA in ketogenic diet research, the authors suggest:
- Clearly reporting the technical characteristics of the equipment used;
- Reporting raw BIA data to support the development of new predictive equations or the validation of existing ones;
- Using predictive equations specific to the study population to enhance accuracy;
- Considering the use of bioelectrical impedance vector analysis (BIVA) to monitor fluid changes and their distribution, which is particularly important for understanding body composition changes under a ketogenic diet.

In conclusion, although BIA has great potential as a convenient and cost-effective tool for monitoring body composition changes during a ketogenic diet, there are some limitations and shortcomings in current research practices. Implementing the above best practice recommendations can significantly improve the application of BIA in this field.