Abstract:To help understand modern financial accounting theory ('FAT') and its role in the development of finance and business, I consider two current mainstream histories of its development and offer a third alternative. The standard setters’ version is that increasingly FAT is rationally derived from a basically coherent conceptual framework, currently focused on 'comprehensive income' as measured by 'changes in assets and liabilities', in turn preferably measured at fair values. However, examination here of several recent FASB/IASB standards and exposure drafts shows that instead they unavoidably bear the marks of the history of a variety of now embedded practices that have shaped thinking about, and vested interests in, what is 'good accounting'. By contrast, some recent academic versions of history focus on how 'conservative', historical-cost based accounting principles have rationally evolved to provide an anchor on which to base appraisal of firms’ and managers’ performance, prospects and risks, and supply the kind of information that investors and other parties in the capital markets need to help overcome the information asymmetry between them and corporate managers. After analyzing the limitations of this second type of history, I argue that even a brief genealogical examination of the conditions of possibility that have led to the growth and changes in accounting and auditing practices and discourses, and in the power-knowledge relations that they have engendered at different stages over the millennia of recorded history, suggests that their power has always been more that of 'institutional rationalized myth'. The twin rational myths of the objectivity of accounting and of auditing together provide the structure that offers the comfort necessary to enable the various agents in the modern, increasingly global, economy to undertake and finance the risks of acting 'at a distance' and across time. This modern, grammatocentric accountability increasingly extends throughout the institutions that coordinate modern societies, in the rising East as well as in the established West. Exploring how much of FAT is rational and reflects some objective 'economic reality' and how much is myth and is subjectively, socially constructed; and, again, how much might be improved and how much is intractable, are the major questions now for accounting, auditing and finance policy-making and research. This requires further detailed comparative international historical understanding of how accounting and auditing have variously operated, within businesses and other organizations and in shaping markets, across different countries and cultures.

Words and Numbers: Financialization and Accounting Standard Setting in the United Kingdom

Is accounting a matter for bookkeepers only? The effects of IFRS adoption on the financialisation of economy

The political economy of International Accounting Standards

Challenges to Regulatory Harmonization and Standard-Setting: The Case of Environmental Accounting in the US and Canada

"One bank, two cultural identities": a case study of Chinese and British influence on the financial practices of HSBC bank

Accounting for Society: Examining the Interplay between Financial Reporting and Social Responsibility

Understanding and improving the language of business: How accounting and corporate reporting research can better serve business and society

Integrating financial, social and environmental accounting

Understanding the changes in accounting thought

Fair Value vs Conservatism? Aspects of the History of Accounting, Auditing, Business and Finance from Ancient Mesopotamia to Modern China

Management accounting change in a bank

Impact of Financial Reporting Transparency on Investor Decision-Making

Expanding the politics of measurement in sustainable finance: Reconceptualizing environmental, social and governance information as infrastructure

Mental accounting matters

A Fundamentalist Perspective on Accounting and Implications for Accounting Research

Unintended institutionalization: how the politics of symbolic fiscal practices shapes economic policy

Beyond the 'tyranny of metrics'? Indicator literacy in sustainable finance

Cost-Benefit Analysis of Monetary and Financial Statistics

Past, present, and future of carbon accounting: Insights from scholarly research

Accounting Standards Harmonization and Financial Integration

Performing finance: the industry, the media and its image