Abstract:Abstract Environmental sustainability, social engagement and robust governance gained growing attention from consumers and investors alike, leading to what we call ‘ESG finance’. ESG criteria are now shaping the behaviour and choices of enterprises, investors and consumers. Indeed laudable, the increased importance of ESG finance could raise concerns about the robustness underneath this new set of financial products. Moreover, the reliability of ESG-related data and information shared by companies may also be challenged due to the ability of those indicators to shape the public profile of companies and their attractiveness for investors. A new breed of ESG rankings and ratings is widening the metrics that consumers and investors use to make informed decisions about their consumption and investment. Yet, such rankings and ratings hinge on the individual disclosure approaches of the interested companies. This article wishes to complement available data and information about specific emissions data released by companies with the ESG disclosure levels, in particular relating to the “environment” dimension. Based on these disclosure levels, the authors build a new metric with the purpose of reducing asymmetric information and promoting more responsible investment. Starting from ESG-related data and publicly available information, a new disclosure-adjusted pollution index (namely, the GHG Scope-1 DAdj index) is developed. The second part of the article puts forward an empirical analysis on the basis of this new index, suggesting that the rush to ESG finance could be poised to generate leeway for new types of asymmetries and possible distortions in investment decision-making, also providing grounds for potentially reckless speculative attitudes, especially in the domain of product development of financial instruments that may generate new forms of risk for investors. Using the GHG Scope-1 DAdj index makes a few companies less environmentally friendly and interesting for investors who are seeking responsible and sustainable investment options. The innovative index and the empirical analysis lead the authors to suggest to “split the domains of ESG” to better gauge the relation between impact and compliance costs for companies as the individual components of environment, social engagement and governance are considered separately.

Beyond the 'tyranny of metrics'? Indicator literacy in sustainable finance

Expanding the politics of measurement in sustainable finance: Reconceptualizing environmental, social and governance information as infrastructure

Squaring the Circle, or a Quantified Rating of ESG Reports

Biases in 'sustainable finance' metrics could hinder lending to those that need it most

Turning investments green in bond markets: Qualification, devices and morality

Measuring Social Dimensions of Sustainability at the Community Level: An Illustrative but Cautionary Tale

ESG Disclosure and Sustainability Transition: A New Metric and Emerging Trends in Responsible Investments

Mandatory Disclosure of Standardized Sustainability Metrics: The Case of the EU Taxonomy Regulation

Unravelling the Impact of Financial Literacy on the Intention of Indian Retail Investors to Adopt Socially Responsible Investments: The Interplay of Social Self-Efficacy as a Mediating Mechanism

Sustainable Finance: A Journey Toward ESG and Climate Risk

The Financial Market of Environmental Indices

Sustainable finance versus environmental policy: Does greenwashing justify a taxonomy for sustainable investments?

Process Tracing the Policy Impact of ‘Indicators’

Green, Alternative or Business as Usual? Critical Geographies of Sustainable Finance

The influence of environmental and social criteria in green finance decision-making: insights and trends

ALIGNING PROFIT WITH PLANET: STRATEGIES AND IMPLICATIONS OF SUSTAINABLE FINANCE IN THE MODERN ECONOMY

Understanding the Role of Finance in Sustainable Development: A Qualitative Study on Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Practices

Blueprints to Benefits: Towards an Index to Measure the Impact of Sustainable Product Development on the Firm's Bottom Line

ESG Indicators as Organizational Performance Goals: Do Rating Agencies Encourage a Holistic Approach?

Sustainability Manifesto for Financial Products: Carbon Equivalence Principle

Mapping sustainable investing: Exploring ambiguities and consistencies among sustainable indices