Quantifying the containment efficiency of underground water-sealed oil storage caverns: Method and case study

Huan Liu,Liping Qiao,Shuhong Wang,Wei Li,Jie Liu,Zhechao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tust.2020.103797

IF: 6.9

2021-04-01

Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology

Abstract:<p>Most studies concerning the evaluation of containment property for underground water-sealed oil storage caverns have focused on containment safety. However, the water inflow into storage caverns has not been considered. Too great of a water inflow into storage caverns leads to waste in water resources and increased cost of wastewater treatment. In this study, a quantitative index of containment efficiency is proposed, which is related to both the containment safety and the water inflow into storage caverns for the safe and economic operation of underground water-sealed oil storage caverns, i.e., the degree of containment safety that can be provided by the unit water inflow into storage caverns. An evaluation method for containment efficiency is presented from the perspective of optimization of Water Curtain System (WCS) parameters and is applied to an underground water-sealed oil storage cavern. The influences of the WCS parameters and the geometric parameters of rock fractures on the containment efficiency are investigated using the Discrete Element Method (DEM). There is a nonlinear relationship between the quantitative index of containment efficiency and the WCS parameters, as well as the relationship between the quantitative index of containment efficiency and the geometric parameters of rock fractures. An evaluation of containment property for the storage cavern is conducted using the existing containment safety criterion, and the evaluation results are compared with those of containment efficiency. The rationality of the quantitative index of containment efficiency is demonstrated.</p>

construction & building technology,engineering, civil

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to address the safety and economic issues of underground water-sealed oil storage. Specifically, the paper proposes a quantitative indicator—"sealing efficiency"—to evaluate how underground water-sealed oil storage can ensure safety while reducing water resource wastage and wastewater treatment costs.

#### Main Research Content:
1. **Proposing the concept of sealing efficiency**: Combining sealing safety and the amount of water entering the oil storage, sealing efficiency is defined as the degree of sealing safety provided per unit of water inflow.
2. **Evaluation method**: From the perspective of optimizing Water Curtain System (WCS) parameters, an evaluation method for sealing efficiency is proposed and applied to actual cases of underground water-sealed oil storage.
3. **Influence factor analysis**: Using the Discrete Element Method (DEM), the impact of WCS parameters and rock fracture geometric parameters on sealing efficiency is studied.
4. **Nonlinear relationship verification**: It is found that there is a nonlinear relationship between sealing efficiency and WCS parameters as well as rock fracture geometric parameters, which is verified by comparing with existing sealing safety standards.

#### Research Background:
1. **Importance of sealing safety**: Ensuring that the underground water pressure is higher than the pressure of oil and gas inside the storage to prevent leakage.
2. **Insufficiency of existing research**: Most studies focus only on sealing safety, neglecting the issues of resource wastage and increased wastewater treatment costs due to excessive water inflow.

#### Methods and Steps:
1. **Obtaining the seepage field**: Through numerical simulation, analytical solutions, or field monitoring, obtain the seepage field of the underground oil storage.
2. **Calculating water inflow and safety margin**: In numerical simulations, calculate the water inflow and determine the safety margin based on the distribution of underground water pressure.
3. **Evaluating sealing efficiency**: Set different conditions for WCS parameters and rock fracture geometric parameters to assess the quantitative indicator of sealing efficiency.

Through this research, the paper aims to provide a new evaluation method for the safe and economical operation of underground water-sealed oil storage.