Abstract:There has been growing interest in $f(Q)$ gravity, which has led to significant advancements in the field. However, it is important to note that most studies in this area were based on the coincident gauge, thus overlooking the impact of the connection degrees of freedom. In this work, we pay special attention to the connection when studying perturbations in general teleparallel, metric teleparallel, and symmetric teleparallel theories of gravity. We do not just examine perturbations in the metric, but also in the affine connection. To illustrate this, we investigate cosmological perturbations in $f(G)$, $f(T)$, and $f(Q)$ gravity with and without matter in form of an additional scalar field for spatially flat and curved FLRW geometries. Our perturbative analysis reveals that for general $f(Q)$ backgrounds, there are up to seven degrees of freedom, depending on the background connection. This is in perfect agreement with the upper bound on degrees of freedom established for the first time in $\href{<a class="link-external link-https" href="https://doi.org/10.1002/prop.202300185" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>}{Fortschr. Phys. 2023, 2300185}$. In $f(G)$ and $f(T)$ gravity theories, only two tensor modes propagate in the gravity sector on generic curved cosmological backgrounds, indicating strong coupling problems. In the context of $f(Q)$ cosmology, we find that for a particular background connection, where all seven modes propagate, there is at least one ghost degree of freedom. For all other choices of the connection the ghost can be avoided at the cost of strong coupling problem, where only four degrees of freedom propagate. Hence, all of the cosmologies within the teleparallel families of theories in form of $f(G)$, $f(T)$, and $f(Q)$ suffer either from strong coupling or from ghost instabilities. A direct coupling of the matter field to the connection or non-minimal couplings might alter these results.

Apparent ghosts and spurious degrees of freedom in non-local theories

Pathological Character of Modifications to Coincident General Relativity: Cosmological Strong Coupling and Ghosts in Theories

Non-locality of the C- and D-theories

Pathological Character of Modifications to Coincident General Relativity: Cosmological Strong Coupling and Ghosts in $f(\Q)$ Theories

Revisiting a Parity Violating Gravity Model Without Ghost Instability: Local Lorentz Covariance

Apparent dark matter as a non-local manifestation of emergent gravity

Global and Local Stability for Ghosts Coupled to Positive Energy Degrees of Freedom

Gauss-Bonnet dynamical compactification scenarios and their ghosts in the tensor sectors

Brane induced gravity: From a no-go to a no-ghost theorem

Quantum gravity inspired nonlocal quantum dynamics preserving the classical limit

Cosmological perturbations and structure formation in nonlocal infrared modifications of general relativity

Ghost Cosmology: Exact Solutions, Transitions Between Standard Cosmologies and Ghost Dark Energy/Matter Evolution

A non-relativistic theory of quantum mechanics and gravity with local modulus symmetry

Can nonlocal gravity really explain dark energy?

A closed universe with hybrid nonlocality

On the Degrees of Freedom of $R^2$ Gravity in Flat Spacetime

Cosmological teleparallel perturbations

Time-convolutionless cosmological master equations: Late-time resummations and decoherence for non-local kernels

Nonpropagating ghost in covariant $f(Q)$ gravity

Nonlocal Quantum Effects in Cosmology