Abstract:We study the degrees of freedom of $R^2$ gravity in flat spacetime with two approaches. By rewriting the theory a la Stueckelberg, and implementing Lorentz-like gauges to the metric perturbations, we confirm that the pure theory propagates one scalar degree of freedom, while the full theory contains two tensor modes in addition. We then consider the degrees of freedom by directly examining the metric perturbations. We show that the degrees of freedom of the full theory match with those obtained with the manifestly covariant approach. In contrast, we find that the pure $R^2$ gravity has no degrees of freedom. We show that a similar discrepancy between the two approaches appears also in a theory dual to the three-form, and appears due to the Lorentz-like gauges, which lead to the fictitious modes even after the residual gauge redundancy has been taken into account. At first sight, this implies a discontinuity between the full theory and the pure case. By studying the first-order corrections of the full $R^2$ gravity beyond the linear regime, we show that at high-energies, both scalar and tensor degrees of freedom become strongly coupled. This implies that the apparent discontinuity of pure and full $R^2$ gravity is just an artefact of the perturbation theory, and further supports the absence of degrees of freedom in the pure $R^2$ gravity.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the degrees of freedom of the R² gravitational theory in flat spacetime. Specifically, the author studied the degrees of freedom of pure R² gravity and full R² gravity (i.e., R² gravity including the Einstein - Hilbert term) through two different methods: 1. **Explicit covariant method**: This method uses the Stueckelberg trick and the Lorentz - type gauge condition to study the degrees of freedom. The results show that: - **Pure R² gravity**: It has one scalar degree of freedom. - **Full R² gravity**: It has two tensor degrees of freedom and one scalar degree of freedom. 2. **Direct method**: This method is based on the methods of cosmological perturbation theory and directly analyzes metric perturbations. The results show that: - **Pure R² gravity**: It has no degrees of freedom. - **Full R² gravity**: It has two tensor degrees of freedom and one scalar degree of freedom. The paper also explored the reasons for this difference and compared it with the theory of three - form fields. For three - form fields, the two methods also give different results, but in the case of non - zero mass, the results of the two methods are consistent. ### Main problem summary 1. **Degrees of freedom of pure R² gravity**: The explicit covariant method shows that pure R² gravity has one scalar degree of freedom, while the direct method shows that pure R² gravity has no degrees of freedom. 2. **Degrees of freedom of full R² gravity**: Both methods show that full R² gravity has two tensor degrees of freedom and one scalar degree of freedom. 3. **Degrees of freedom of three - form fields**: For three - form fields with zero mass, the explicit covariant method shows that there is one scalar degree of freedom, while the direct method shows that there is no degrees of freedom. For three - form fields with non - zero mass, the results of the two methods are consistent, both showing that there is one scalar degree of freedom. ### Main contributions of the paper - **Revealing the differences between different methods**: By comparing the explicit covariant method and the direct method, the paper reveals the different conclusions that different methods may lead to when dealing with pure R² gravity and three - form fields. - **Explaining the reasons for the differences**: The paper explored the reasons for these differences, especially the spurious modes that may be caused by the Lorentz - type gauge condition when introducing additional gauge redundancies. - **Behavior in the high - energy limit**: The paper further studied the behavior of full R² gravity in the high - energy limit and found that both scalar and tensor modes will become strongly coupled, which indicates that the apparent discontinuity between pure R² gravity and full R² gravity is just an artifact of perturbation theory. Through these studies, the paper provides a new perspective for understanding the degrees of freedom of R² gravity and three - form fields and lays the foundation for further research.

On the Degrees of Freedom of $R^2$ Gravity in Flat Spacetime

On the degrees of freedom of R2 gravity in flat spacetime

A short note on dynamics and degrees of freedom in $2d$ classical gravity

Degrees of Freedom in modified Teleparallel Gravity

Dirac-Bergmann analysis and Degrees of Freedom of Coincident $f(Q)$-gravity

On the degrees of freedom count on singular phase space submanifolds

Dirac–Bergmann analysis and degrees of freedom of coincident f(Q)-gravity

Degrees of Freedom of New General Relativity: Type 2, Type 3, Type 5, and Type 8

Spatial covariant gravity with two degrees of freedom in the presence of an auxiliary scalar field: perturbation analysis

Quantum Theory, Gravity and Second Order Geometry

Removing spurious degrees of freedom from EFT of gravity

Test-field limit of metric nonlinear gravity theories

Revisiting Stability in New General Relativity

$f(R,\square R)$-gravity and equivalency with the modified GUP Scalar field models

The particle content of $R^2$ gravity revisited

Degrees of freedom of gravitational radiation with positive cosmological constant

BRST Formalism of $f(R)$ Gravity