Western European Variation in the Organization of Esophageal Cancer Surgical Care

Maurits R Visser,Daan M Voeten,Suzanne S Gisbertz,Jelle P Ruurda,Michael P Achiam,Magnus Nilsson,Sheraz R Markar,Manuel Pera,Riccardo Rosati,Guillaume Piessen,Philippe Nafteux,Christian A Gutschow,Peter P Grimminger,Jari V Räsänen,John V Reynolds,Hans-Olaf Johannessen,Pedro Vieira,Michael Weitzendorfer,Aristotelis Kechagias,Mark I van Berge Henegouwen,Richard van Hillegersberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/dote/doae033

2024-04-26

Diseases of the Esophagus

Abstract:Abstract Reasons for structural and outcome differences in esophageal cancer surgery in Western Europe remain unclear. This questionnaire study aimed to identify differences in the organization of esophageal cancer surgical care in Western Europe. A cross-sectional international questionnaire study was conducted among upper gastrointestinal (GI) surgeons from Western Europe. One surgeon per country was selected based on scientific output and active membership in the European Society for Diseases of the Esophagus or (inter)national upper GI committee. The questionnaire consisted of 51 structured questions on the structural organization of esophageal cancer surgery, surgical training, and clinical audit processes. Between October 2021 and October 2022, 16 surgeons from 16 European countries participated in this study. In 5 countries (31%), a volume threshold was present ranging from 10 to 26 annual esophagectomies, in 7 (44%) care was centralized in designated centers, and in 4 (25%) no centralizing regulations were present. The number of centers performing esophageal cancer surgery per country differed from 4 to 400, representing 0.5–4.9 centers per million inhabitants. In 4 countries (25%), esophageal cancer surgery was part of general surgical training and 8 (50%) reported the availability of upper GI surgery fellowships. A national audit for upper GI surgery was present in 8 (50%) countries. If available, all countries use the audit to monitor the quality of care. Substantial differences exist in the organization and centralization of esophageal cancer surgical care in Western Europe. The exchange of experience in the organizational aspects of care could further improve the results of esophageal cancer surgical care in Europe.

gastroenterology & hepatology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the reasons for the significant differences in the organizational structure and results of esophageal cancer surgeries among Western European countries. Specifically, the study aims to identify the differences in the organization of esophageal cancer surgical care in Western European countries through questionnaires, including the centralization of surgical services, the availability and organization of clinical audits, and the organization of esophageal cancer surgical training. The researchers hope that by understanding these differences, they can promote the exchange of experiences among countries, thereby further improving the quality and effectiveness of esophageal cancer surgical care in Europe.

The research background mentions that although some countries such as the Netherlands, Denmark and the United Kingdom have reported the positive impact of their national audits on improving the quality of patient treatment, there are still significant differences in treatment characteristics and surgical results among Western European countries. An important factor in these differences is the structural organization of esophageal cancer surgical care, especially the impact of centralization. Multiple studies have shown that esophageal cancer surgeries performed in high - volume centers have lower mortality rates and better survival rates. Therefore, the objective of this study is to explore the differences in the organizational structure of esophageal cancer surgical care in 16 Western European countries, in order to find ways to improve the quality of care and results.