Abstract:Modern China, Ahead of Print. Since the 1980s, three paradigms have dominated the historical study of commercial associations—class analysis, modernization, and "public sphere"/"civil society"—but all three are imbued with and insist upon a binary opposition between state and society. These paradigms produce an understanding of commercial associations as part of a Western-style "bourgeois public sphere," itself part of "civil society," standing in opposition to the state. These misinterpretations were only strengthened by the complete state-ification of commercial associations in China after 1949. Studies of the history of commercial associations, trapped in this theoretical pitfall, cannot produce convincing historical research, even with abundant empirical data, nor can they provide experiential models for the development of contemporary commercial associations. Instead, if we focus on practice, we discover that modern commercial associations were part of a "third sphere," an in-between space within the paradoxical institutional framework of China's highly centralized government and minimalist administrative system. The semiformal governance mechanism operative within the third sphere reflected the close relationship and mutual shaping at work between the state and local society rather than a binary opposition between them. Applying these insights on the history of commercial associations to the practices of contemporary "commercial consultative associations" allows us to see that the semiformal administrative traditions embedded in the "third sphere" continue to quietly operate, which has immense significance for the future development of commercial associations in China.

Rethinking “the Third Sphere”: The Dualistic Unity of State and Society in China, Past and Present

Political Risk of Centralization and the Vertical Separation of Powers:Reform of Contemporary Social Management System from a Historical Perspective

In Search of a Long-Term Development Path for China: Starting from Differences between Assigning Responsibility and Contracting

The Soft Control of the State Will on Community Public Affairs An Expansion on Philip Huang’s Concept of"the Third Realm between State and Society"

The Past, Present, and Future of Commercial Associations in China: Reflections on Theory and the Pathways of Practice

Administration: Reconsideration of the Theory of Relation Between a Country and Its Citizen Society

The Expansion of State and the Shrinkage of Civil Society: A Continuing Tendency Emerging in the Qing Period

The Public Sphere in Modern China: Forms, Functions and Self-Understandings—A Case Study of Shanghai

A Global Perspective of the Independence of Social Sciences in China

Introduction to "constitutionalism, Reform, and the Nature of the Chinese State: Dialogues among Western and Chinese Scholars, Iii"

From Dualistic Opposition to Dyadic Integration: Toward a New Political Economy of Chinese Practice

How to Think about Cyber Sovereignty: the Case of China

Understanding China: A Dialogue with Philip Huang

On the Harmonious Society of the Relationship between State and Society

From Macromanagement to Micromanagement——Reflections on Thirty Years of Reform from the Sociological Perspective

In Search of a Social Science Anchored in (chinese) Realities

From Political Decay to Totalism: The Evolution of "Centralization-Decentralization" Mode in Modern China

An Analysis of Researches in Qing's Legal History

A Relational Image of Chinese Bureaucracy

Middle Kingdom Mentalities: Chinese Visions of National Characteristics in the 1990s

The Governance Theory and Reconstruction of Chinese Government's Functions