Abstract:The general question, crucial to an understanding of the internal structure of the nucleon, of how to split the total angular momentum of a photon or gluon into spin and orbital contributions is one of the most important and interesting challenges faced by gauge theories like Quantum Electrodynamics and Quantum Chromodynamics. This is particularly challenging since all QED textbooks state that such an splitting cannot be done for a photon (and a fortiori for a gluon) in a gauge-invariant way, yet experimentalists around the world are engaged in measuring what they believe is the gluon spin! This question has been a subject of intense debate and controversy, ever since, in 2008, it was claimed that such a gauge-invariant split was, in fact, possible. We explain in what sense this claim is true and how it turns out that one of the main problems is that such a decomposition is not unique and therefore raises the question of what is the most natural or physical choice. The essential requirement of measurability does not solve the ambiguities and leads us to the conclusion that the choice of a particular decomposition is essentially a matter of taste and convenience. In this review, we provide a pedagogical introduction to the question of angular momentum decomposition in a gauge theory, present the main relevant decompositions and discuss in detail several aspects of the controversies regarding the question of gauge invariance, frame dependence, uniqueness and measurability. We stress the physical implications of the recent developments and collect into a separate section all the sum rules and relations which we think experimentally relevant. We hope that such a review will make the matter amenable to a broader community and will help to clarify the present situation.

The application of gauge invariance and canonical quantization to the internal structure of gauge field systems

Gauge invariance, Lorentz covariance and canonical quantization in nucleon structure studies

The QCD theta-parameter in canonical quantization

The angular momentum controversy: What's it all about and does it matter?

Conservation of Isotopic Spin and Isotopic Gauge Invariance

Quantum Gauge Equivalence in QED

Gauge transformations and Galilean covariance in nonlinear gauge-coupled quantum fluids

Gauge-Invariant Quantum Fields

Gauge Invariance of a Critical Number of Flavours in QED3

Impact of gauge fixing on angular momentum operators of the covariantly quantized electromagnetic field

Gauge Invariant Propagators and States in Quantum Electrodynamics

Gauge-invariant ground state for canonically quantized Yang-Mills theory

Gauge Symmetry from Integral Viewpoint

Continuity equation and local gauge invariance for the N3LO nuclear Energy Density Functionals

External gauge field coupled quantum dynamics: gauge choices, Heisenberg algebra representations and gauge invariance in general, and the Landau problem in particular

Gauge Covariance and Momentum Space Asymptotically Non-Logarithmic Total Derivatives

Gauge invariant spectral analysis of quark hadronization dynamics

Quantization as a Necessary Condition for Gauge Invariance

QCD condensate contributions to the effective quark potential in a covariant gauge

Canonical quantization of the U(1) gauge field in the right Rindler-wedge in the Rindler coordinates

Gauge Invariance through Gauge Fixing