J. Towe
Abstract:Symmetry and quantization are the two major enterprises of theoretical physics; but some argue that quantization can be derived as a necessary condition for symmetry. It is argued here that the Heisenberg uncertainty principle is a necessary condition for gauge invariance in the 5-dimensional Kaluza-Klein theory.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to start from the 5 - dimensional Kaluza - Klein theory, by hiding the fifth space - time dimension, and maintaining a specific symmetry (i.e., symmetry reduction \( \text{GL}(5)\rightarrow\text{GL}(4)\times\text{U}(1) \)) during the projection onto the 4 - dimensional space - time, so as to derive the quantization conditions, especially the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, as a necessary condition for gauge invariance.
Specifically, the author explores the following points:
1. **Background of the 5 - dimensional Kaluza - Klein theory**:
- The paper reviews the Christoffel connection coefficients in the 5 - dimensional Kaluza - Klein theory, which describe the geometric structure in 5 - dimensional general relativity.
- By introducing the "Kaluza - Klein condition" \( \frac{\partial g_{\alpha\nu}}{\partial x^5}=0 \), the author shows how to project the 5 - dimensional theory onto the 4 - dimensional space - time, and under this projection, the additional connection coefficients can be interpreted as the electromagnetic field tensor \( F_{\mu\nu} \).
2. **Symmetry reduction**:
- The projection process requires symmetry reduction \( \text{GL}(5)\rightarrow\text{GL}(4)\times\text{U}(1) \), where \( \text{GL}(5) \) represents the general rotation group in 5 - dimensional space - time, \( \text{GL}(4) \) represents the general rotation group in 4 - dimensional space - time, and \( \text{U}(1) \) represents the 1 - parameter phase transformation group.
- This symmetry reduction means that the interactions in the 4 - dimensional space - time must maintain \( \text{U}(1) \) invariance, that is, charge conservation.
3. **Derivation of quantization conditions**:
- The author considers the propagation of a classical wave in the 4 - dimensional space - time and analyzes the invariance of this wave under \( \text{U}(1) \) transformation.
- Through this analysis, the author derives a quantization condition, that is, \( P_{\mu}dx^{\mu}=2\pi n \), where \( n \) is an integer, \( P_{\mu} \) is the 4 - momentum, and \( dx^{\mu} \) is the 4 - displacement.
- Finally, the author relates this condition to the Heisenberg uncertainty principle and obtains \( P_{\mu}dx^{\mu}\geq 2h \), which is a fundamental relation in quantum mechanics.
4. **Conclusion**:
- By hiding the fifth space - time dimension and maintaining a specific symmetry in the interactions in the 4 - dimensional space - time, the 5 - dimensional Kaluza - Klein theory can be projected onto the 4 - dimensional space - time, manifested as general relativity, classical electrodynamics, and quantum mechanics on astrophysical, macroscopic, and microscopic scales respectively.
- This result shows that quantum mechanics can emerge naturally from classical theories (such as general relativity) without the need to introduce additional assumptions or concepts.
In summary, the main objective of this paper is to show, through the framework of the 5 - dimensional Kaluza - Klein theory, how the quantization conditions (especially the Heisenberg uncertainty principle) emerge naturally as necessary conditions for gauge invariance. This research provides a new perspective for understanding the relationship between quantum mechanics and classical theories.