Moral decision-making at night and the impact of night work with blue-enriched white light or warm white light: a counterbalanced crossover study

Erlend Sunde,Anette Harris,Olav Kjellevold Olsen,Ståle Pallesen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07853890.2024.2331054

IF: 5.348

2024-04-20

Annals of Medicine

Abstract:Background Cognitive function, including moral decision-making abilities, can be impaired by sleep loss. Blue-enriched light interventions have been shown to ameliorate cognitive impairment during night work. This study investigated whether the quality of moral decision-making during simulated night work differed for night work in blue-enriched white light, compared to warm white light.

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is whether there are differences in the quality of moral decision-making under different lighting conditions (blue-enriched white light and warm white light) during night work. Specifically, the researchers aim to evaluate whether the moral decision-making ability during night work under blue-enriched white light and warm white light conditions differs from that during the day, and whether these differences can be moderated by different lighting conditions.

### Background
- **Cognitive Function Impairment**: Sleep deprivation affects cognitive functions, including moral decision-making ability.
- **Blue Light Intervention**: Blue-enriched light interventions have been shown to mitigate cognitive impairment during night work.

### Research Objectives
- **Primary Objective**: To investigate whether there is a difference in the quality of moral decision-making under blue-enriched white light (7000K) and warm white light (2500K) conditions during simulated night work.
- **Secondary Objective**: To assess whether the quality of moral decision-making during night work differs from that during the day.

### Methods
- **Experimental Design**: A balanced crossover design was used, with participants working three consecutive night shifts under blue-enriched white light and warm white light conditions.
- **Measurement Tools**: The Defining Issues Test-2 (DIT-2) was used to assess different levels of moral decision-making, including post-conventional schema (P-score), maintaining norms schema (MN-score), and personal interest schema (PI-score).
- **Data Collection**: The DIT-2 test was conducted at 3:30 AM during the second night shift and again during daytime rest.

### Results
- **Post-Conventional Schema (P-score)**:
- The P-score under warm white light was significantly lower than during the day (p=0.007), while there was no significant difference under blue-enriched white light.
- Overall, the P-score during night work was lower than during the day (p=0.008).
- **Maintaining Norms Schema (MN-score)**:
- The MN-score during night work was generally higher than during the day (p=0.033), but there was no significant difference between different lighting conditions.
- **Personal Interest Schema (PI-score)**:
- There were no significant differences between different lighting conditions and time points.

### Conclusion
- **Night Work under Warm White Light**: Moral decision-making relies more on rules rather than higher-level moral reasoning based on principles.
- **Night Work under Blue-Enriched White Light**: The quality of moral decision-making is relatively better, and blue-enriched white light may have a moderating effect.
- **Further Research**: More studies are needed to validate these preliminary findings.

Through this study, the authors hope to reveal the impact of different lighting conditions on moral decision-making during night work, thereby providing scientific evidence to improve the moral judgment ability of night workers.