Abstract:Centralized vs. decentralized sewage treatment is one of the key issues in the planning of rural sewage treatment (RST) in China due to the country's diverse regional characteristics. There are very limited comprehensive evaluation models for selecting regionally suitable schemes and facilities, particularly for national or provisional scale planning. As a scenario-based multi-attribute decision-making (MADM) issue, this paper develops a novel RST suitability evaluation model by integrating the multi-attribute analytic hierarchy process (AHP) with the technique for order preference by similarity to an ideal solution (TOPSIS). The suitability evaluation model sets up 3 small-centralized and 4 decentralized RST facilities as candidates and includes 12 evaluation indicators that cover economic cost, life cycle environmental impacts , technical features and operations management. Eight generic scenarios are classified for Chinese rural areas based on differences in three major characteristic factors, i.e., population density (PD), the economic development level (EDL), and topographic slope (TS). The universal evaluation results show that a centralized sewage treatment scheme is more suitable for areas with a high PD/high EDL/low TS, while a decentralized scheme is more suitable for areas with a low PD/low EDL/high TS. Sensitivity analysis shows that in regions with a high PD/low EDL, the indicator weight of the construction investment cost in the model has a great influence on the facility suitability ranking. However, in regions with a high PD/high EDL, the ranking is the most sensitive to the indicator weights of the global warming potential and sewage treatment effect. Furthermore, as a spatial decision issue, an RST suitability map of Hunan Province in China is produced at the county level of resolution, and the map is generally consistent with our field knowledge of several counties in Hunan Province. The presented evaluation framework can be integrated into environmental decision support systems in the future to help local and central governments, water utilities, design institutes and other stakeholders scientifically plan RST projects.

Decision support framework adapted to local conditions to select technologies for rural domestic sewage treatment in the Yangtze River Economic Belt

[Evaluation and Optimization of Rural Sewage Treatment Technologies in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River Based on Group Decision Making and Analytic Hierarchy Process]

Suitability evaluation of rural sewage treatment facilities in China considering lifcycle environmental impacts and regional differences

Multi-period evaluation and selection of rural wastewater treatment technologies: a case study

Suitability Evaluation of Rural Sewage Treatment Schemes in China Considering Life-Cycle Environmental Impacts and Regional Differences

To centralize or to decentralize? A systematic framework for optimizing rural wastewater treatment planning

A conceptual framework for a multi-criteria decision support tool to select technologies for resource recovery from urban wastewater

Evaluation of rural wastewater treatment processes in a county of eastern China

Rural domestic sewage treatment in Northeast cold region of China: rational evaluation of technology options

Systematically assess the advancing and limiting factors of using the multi-soil-layering system for treating rural sewage in China: From the economic, social, and environmental perspectives

Socioeconomic Constraints on the Technological Choices in Rural Sewage Treatment

Assessment of Economic, Environmental, and Technological Sustainability of Rural Sanitation and Toilet Infrastructure and Decision Support Model for Improvement

Sustainable infrastructure projects in balancing urban–rural development: towards the goal of efficiency and equity

Optimization of rural domestic sewage treatment mode based on life cycle assessment method: A case study of Wuzhong District, Suzhou City, China

Machine learning assisted combined systems of wastewater treatment plants with constructed wetlands optimal decision-making

Research on Application of Anaerobic Treatment Technology for Domestic Sewage in Rural Areas

Application of Decentralized Wastewater Treatment Technology in Rural Domestic Wastewater Treatment

Efficiency Assessment of Rural Domestic Sewage Treatment Facilities by a Slacked-Based DEA Model

Selection and Analysis of Treatment Technologies for Rural Domestic Sewage in Taihu Lake Area

Methodological framework for wastewater treatment plants delivering expanded service: Economic tradeoffs and technological decisions

Constructing and selecting optimal sustainable sanitation system based on expanded structured decision-making for global sanitation and resources crisis