The Effect of Leader Perfectionism on Employee Deviance: An Interpersonal Relationship Perspective
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s454596
IF: 3.974
2024-04-18
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Hua Qiang Wang, 1 Xin Jiang, 1 Dan Li, 2 Xin Jin, 3 Jie Zhang 1 1 School of Economics and Management, Yangtze University, Jingzhou, Hubei Province, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Business Administration, Zhongnan University of Economics and Law, WuHan, Hubei Province, People's Republic of China; 3 Wuchang Shouyi University, Wuhan, Hubei Province, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Xin Jin, Email Purpose: Despite growing evidence of significant role of leader perfectionism in the workplace, few theoretical accounts have delved into intricate dynamics of interpersonal relationships impacted by leader perfectionism, nor have they explored the extent to which these interactions might stimulate employee unethical behavior. From an interpersonal relationship perspective, based on interpersonal complementarity theory, this study proposes a link between leader perfectionism and employee deviant behavior while assessing the mediating impact of supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict, and the moderating influence of employee narcissism. Methods: This study employed three-wave surveys, with 335 employees (female 55.8%, 26– 35 years old 67.4%, bachelor's degree 61.5%, worked 3– 10 years 67.4%, worked with their current leader 1– 5 years 66.3%) across 11 enterprises in Chinato reduce the risk of common method bias. On this basis, MPLUS 7.4 was used to test the confirmatory factor analysis of data, and SPSS 24.0 was used to test the hypotheses. Results: (1) Leader perfectionism has a positive effect on supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict. (2) Leader perfectionism has a significantly positive effect on employee deviant behavior via supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict. (3) Employee narcissism positively moderates the relationship between leader perfectionism and supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict, and further positively moderates the indirect effect of leader perfectionism on employee deviant behavior via supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict. Conclusion: This study reveals the mechanism of how employee through deviant behavior as a opposition to leader perfectionism from an interpersonal relationship perspective, which provides theoretical and practical implications for reducing the negative impact of leader perfectionism and employee deviant behavior. Keywords: leader perfectionism, employee narcissism, supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict, employee deviant behavior, an interpersonal relationship perspective Leader perfectionism, a common personality trait, describes a leader who sets exceptionally high standards for employees and demands that employees meet those standards without mistakes and defects. 1–3 Recently, given the unique effectiveness of perfectionist leaders (eg, Steve Jobs & Elon Musk), an increasing number of scholars have joined the research discussion to explore the workplace implications of perfectionist tendencies among leaders. 4–6 However, these studies on perfectionism in leadership only focus on the stress or the resource perspective 1–3 with a lack of exploration of the impact of leader perfectionism on employees through a supervisor-subordinate relationship interaction perspective, and the impact of employee personality traits on this process. Meanwhile, most of the research on perfectionism in leadership explores the impact of leader perfectionism on employees outputs about task performance, such as employee work engagement and creativity, 1–3 lack of exploration of the impact of leader perfectionism on employees outputs about ethics. Thus, this study will explore the ethical impact of leader perfectionism from a supervisor-subordinate relationship interaction perspective. The concept of leader perfectionism is a specific application of other-oriented perfectionism, as proposed by Hewitt & Flett (1991), 7 within leader personality traits, defined as a leader's perfectionistic tendency towards employees rather than to themselves. 1,8 In the realm of other-oriented perfectionism, exceedingly high demands placed upon others that are accompanied by dominance and excessive control may strain relationships. 1,7,8 Concurrently, leaders with a perfectionist tendency may exhibit hostility and criticism towards employees, 2,3 all of these characteristics are extremely likely to cause relationship conflicts with employees. 9,10 As one of the most crucial factors from the perspective of interpersonal relationship, supervisor-subordinate relationship conflict is an important consequence of a leader's personality trait, and is highly correlated with adverse employee outcomes. 9,1 -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary