Abstract:A significant challenge to measuring human-automation trust is the amount of construct proliferation, models, and questionnaires with highly variable validation. However, all agree that trust is a crucial element of technological acceptance, continued usage, fluency, and teamwork. Herein, we synthesize a consensus model for trust in human-automation interaction by performing a meta-analysis of validated and reliable trust survey instruments. To accomplish this objective, this work identifies the most frequently cited and best-validated human-automation and human-robot trust questionnaires, as well as the most well-established factors, which form the dimensions and antecedents of such trust. To reduce both confusion and construct proliferation, we provide a detailed mapping of terminology between questionnaires. Furthermore, we perform a meta-analysis of the regression models that emerged from those experiments which used multi-factorial survey instruments. Based on this meta-analysis, we demonstrate a convergent experimentally validated model of human-automation trust. This convergent model establishes an integrated framework for future research. It identifies the current boundaries of trust measurement and where further investigation is necessary. We close by discussing choosing and designing an appropriate trust survey instrument. By comparing, mapping, and analyzing well-constructed trust survey instruments, a consensus structure of trust in human-automation interaction is identified. Doing so discloses a more complete basis for measuring trust emerges that is widely applicable. It integrates the academic idea of trust with the colloquial, common-sense one. Given the increasingly recognized importance of trust, especially in human-automation interaction, this work leaves us better positioned to understand and measure it.

Mathematical Modeling of the Dynamics of Trust in Automation

A review of mathematical models of human trust in automation

Computational Modeling of the Dynamics of Human Trust During Human–Machine Interactions

Toward Quantifying Trust Dynamics: How People Adjust Their Trust After Moment-to-Moment Interaction With Automation

An Empirical Model of Cultural Factors on Trust in Automation

Converging Measures and an Emergent Model: A Meta-Analysis of Human-Automation Trust Questionnaires

Modeling and Predicting Trust Dynamics in Human-Robot Teaming: A Bayesian Inference Approach

Dynamics of Trust in Automation and Interactive Decision Making During Driving Simulation Tasks

Human Trust-based Feedback Control: Dynamically varying automation transparency to optimize human-machine interactions

A Meta-Analysis of Factors Influencing the Development of Trust in Automation

Trusting Automation: Designing for Responsivity and Resilience

Adaptive Cognitive Mechanisms to Maintain Calibrated Trust and Reliance in Automation

Does automation trust evolve from a leap of faith? An analysis using a reprogrammed pasteurizer simulation task

The Impact of Automation Conditions on Reliance Dynamics and Decision-Making

Toward Mutual Trust Modeling in Human-Robot Collaboration

To Trust or Distrust Trust Measures: Validating Questionnaires for Trust in AI

Real-Time Estimation of Drivers’ Trust in Automated Driving Systems

Understanding Human Drivers' Trust in Highly Automated Vehicles Via Structural Equation Modeling

Trust Dynamics in Human-Autonomy Interaction: Uncover Associations between Trust Dynamics and Personal Characteristics

Stability of Software Trustworthiness Measurements Models

Building Trust Profiles in Conditionally Automated Driving