Abstract:The mean square error is decomposed into systematic and unsystematic errors, further quantitatively describing two scenarios of relationships between different types of errors and evaluation metrics. Evaluation metrics play a pivotal role in the calibration process of hydrological models, serving as objective functions that directly influence the final values of model parameters and significantly affect users' perceptions of model performance. However, the choice and interpretation of evaluation metrics are subjective; therefore, this study provides a more objective framework for assessing model performance. This paper initially explored the applicability of various commonly used evaluation metrics, providing an overview of their limitations. Following this, we decomposed errors by analysing their physical significance and geometric representation in scatter plots, categorizing them into systematic and unsystematic errors. Through the decomposition and derivation of the Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) formula, we established the quantitative relationship among various evaluation metrics. The soil and water assessment tool (SWAT) model was utilized to simulate monthly runoff in the Baishan basin (China), for the period 1994–2017, with NSE serving as the objective function for calibration. Our findings are consistent with previous studies, indicating that the model tends to slightly underestimate high flows while significantly overestimating low flows. Further analysis through error decomposition and the examination of relationships among various evaluation metrics revealed that unsystematic errors were dominant during the spring snowmelt runoff period, while systematic errors prevailed in the dry season. By evaluating the runoff series based on the magnitude of runoff or by categorizing it according to seasons and months, a more stringent assessment of the model's performance was achieved. These findings not only highlight the necessity for careful selection of evaluation metrics but also underscore the significance of our methodological advancements in enhancing hydrological model precision and reliability.

Metering Error Assessment Model Considering Multiple Factors

Optimal Meter Placement for Distribution Network State Estimation: A Circuit Representation Based Milp Approach

A Real-Time Method to Detect the Leakage Location in Urban Water Distribution Networks

A Scheme to Improve the Detection Accuracy of Small Parts of Electric Meters.

Numerical Approach for Water Distribution System Model Calibration Through Incorporation of Multiple Stochastic Prior Distributions.

An Integrated Bottom-Up Approach for Leak Detection in Water Distribution Networks Based on Assessing Parameters of Water Balance Model

An estimation method of smart meter errors based on DREM and DRLS

Real-Time Burst Detection in District Metering Areas in Water Distribution System Based on Patterns of Water Demand with Supervised Learning

Leakage Identification in Water Distribution Networks with Error Tolerance Capability

Measurement error analysis and accuracy improvement method based on gateway meter

A Novel Efficient Model for Gas Compressibility Factor Based on GMDH Network

Using smart meters data to model customer water consumption and evaluate customer flow patterns

Measurement error prediction-based reliability assessment framework for electric metering devices under harsh natural environments

An Online Accuracy Evaluation Method for Smart Electricity Meter Calibration Devices Based on Mutual Correlations of Calibration Data

Optimization on Metering Accuracy of Smart Electricity Meter by Temperature Compensation

Research on intelligent analysis device for dynamic error of electric energy

Design of a Flow Automatic Calibration System Based on the Master Meter and Dynamic Weighing Methods

Online verification and management scheme of gateway meter flow in the power system by machine learning

Multiple Leakage Detection and Isolation in District Metering Areas Using a Multistage Approach

Burst Detection in District Metering Areas Using Deep Learning Method

A comprehensive method for error separation in hydrological modelling