Abstract:Older adults are frequent victims of financial scams. Previous behavioral research suggests that this may be due to systematic biases in how they make decisions about whom to trust: for instance, Lempert et al. (2022) found that relative to younger adults, older adults were more likely to base decisions about whether to re-engage with someone on how generous that person looked, rather than on their memory for how they had previously behaved. Here, we aimed to identify the neural correlates of these age-dependent changes in social decision-making in order to clarify the mechanism by which they emerge. Using functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), we measured neural activity while a total of 86 participants — 45 younger and 41 older adults — learned about how much of a $10 endowment an individual, represented by a picture of their face, was willing to share with them in a dictator game. After this encoding phase, participants then made decisions about whom they wanted to play another round of the dictator game with. In line with previous findings, we found that older adults did not reliably prefer to re-engage with people who had proven themselves to be generous. This bias was the result of several factors: (1) older adults had worse associative memory for how much each person had shared, possibly due to an age-dependent decrease in neural activity in the medial temporal lobe (MTL) during encoding, (2) older adults had a stronger tendency to re-engage with familiar over novel faces regardless of their past behavior, and (3) while activity in value-responsive brain regions tracked with how generous a face looked across the age range, older adults were less able to inhibit the influence of these irrelevant perceptual features when it was necessary to do so. In line with this behavioral effect, younger adults showed greater activation in the inferior frontal gyrus (IFG) during choices that required suppressing irrelevant perceptual features in favor of associative memory. Taken together, our findings highlight age-dependent changes in both the ability to encode relevant information and to adaptively deploy it in service of social decisions.

Counterfactual curiosity in real decisions: The roles of outcome valence and aging

Counterfactual curiosity: motivated thinking about what might have been

Consumer Search with Anticipated Regret

The asymmetric impact of decision-making confidence on regret and relief

Differential impacts of healthy cognitive aging on directed and random exploration.

Striatal Sensitivity to Personal Responsibility in a Regret-Based Decision-Making Task

The Critical Role of the Orbitofrontal Cortex for Regret in an Economic Decision-Making Task.

Age differences in the neural basis of decision-making under uncertainty

Uncertainty increases curiosity, but decreases happiness

Counterfactual thoughts in complex causal domain: content, benefits, and implications for their function

The Neural Basis of Regret and Relief During a Sequential Risk-Taking Task

Dissociated Deficits of Anticipated and Experienced Regret in At-Risk Suicidal Individuals

Metacognition of curiosity: People underestimate the seductive lure of non-instrumental information

The Influence of Aging Stereotype on Young Adults’ Decision-making

Neural correlates of age-related changes in social decisions from episodic memory

Ignorance is Bliss: A Game of Regret

The role of memory in counterfactual valuation.

Older adults process the probability of winning sooner but weigh it less during lottery decisions

Older adults' decision‐making following bad advice

To know or not to know? Curiosity and the value of prospective information in animals

Attentional deployment impacts neural response to regret