Aqueous Zr/Hf(IV)-Oxo Cluster Speciation and Separation

Alexander Roseborough,Ryan Loughran,Christopher Colla,May Nyman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-9d08f

2024-09-02

Abstract:Many industrial separations of chemically-similar elements are achieved by solvent extraction, exploiting differences in speciation and solubility across aqueous-organic interfaces. We recently identified [OM4(OH)6(SCN)12]4- (OM4, M=Zr/HfIV) tetrahedral oxoclusters as the main species in industrial processes that produce nuclear-grade Zr and Hf from crude ore. However, the isostructural/isoelectronic OM4-oxoclusters did not explain the selective extraction of Hf into the organic phase. Here we have characterized heterometal Hf-Zr clusters in solution and the solid-state yielding key information about their fundamentally different chemistry that engenders separation. Clusters prepared with both ammonium (industrial process) and tetramethylammonium counter cations revealed that 1) mixed-metal clusters (instead of self-sorted) assemble, and 2) Hf-rich OM4 selectively precipitates over Zr-rich OM4, providing a separation process that does not require an organic extractant. Mass spectrometry, small-angle X-ray scattering, solution-state 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, and solid-state 17O NMR evidence both mixed-metal speciation and selective Hf-precipitation. Raman spectroscopy suggests greater Zr-ligand lability than Hf-ligand lability, consistent with higher aqueous solubility of Zr-rich clusters, enabling both extraction and precipitation-based separation. Fundamentally, these studies also identify a key difference between these chemically similar elements that has enabled diversification of Zr-polyoxocation chemistry over the last decade, while Hf-polyoxocation chemistry lags.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the development of a new method for metal separation that does not rely on organic extractants, by studying the composition and separation mechanisms of zirconium (Zr) and hafnium (Hf) oxoclusters in aqueous solutions. Specifically, the paper explores the following two core issues:

1. **Self-sorting behavior of metals in oxoclusters**:
- Do metals self-sort when forming oxoclusters, or do they form statistical mixtures?
- This question is crucial for understanding the fundamental principles of metal-metal separation.

2. **Impact of chemical assembly and physical processes on separation**:
- Is the separation driven by chemical assembly (such as precipitation) or physical processes (such as solvent extraction)?
- The authors particularly focus on achieving the separation of Zr and Hf through selective precipitation of Hf-rich oxoclusters, providing new insights for the industrial production of nuclear-grade hafnium and zirconium.

The paper employs various characterization techniques (such as mass spectrometry, small-angle X-ray scattering, solution NMR, solid-state NMR, and Raman spectroscopy) to study the properties of oxoclusters with different Zr/Hf ratios in detail and to verify the selective precipitation behavior of these clusters in aqueous solutions. Ultimately, the authors found that using tetramethylammonium (TMA) as a counterion, Hf-rich oxoclusters preferentially precipitate, thereby achieving effective separation of Zr and Hf. This discovery not only provides a new method for industrial separation but also reveals fundamental differences in the coordination chemistry of Zr and Hf.