Univariate Prediction of Hammett Parameters and Select Relative Reaction Rates Using Loewdin Atomic Charges

Gautam Stroscio,Nir Goldman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-fgz5m

2024-08-29

Abstract:Loewdin charges from density functional theory calculations have been used here to obtain general, univariate linear correlations for the prediction of experimental Hammett parameters and relative reaction rates. While previous studies have established that Hirshfeld and CM5 charges perform strongly as univariate predictors, the near-ubiquitous Loewdin charges have not yet been evaluated. To this end, we assess the predictive capability of Loewdin charges for three chemical systems. First, we show that Loewdin charges outperform Hirshfeld and CM5 charges for Hammett parameter prediction. Second, we see Loewdin charges generally perform comparably to Hirshfeld charges for predicting the relative rates of olefin cleavage by photoexcited nitroarenes. The single case of poor correlation, between relative rates and the Loewdin charges on nitrogen sites, is ameliorated when considering the net charge on the NO2 group. Third, we show that Loewdin, Hirshfeld, and CM5 charges all perform very well for generating correlations for relative reaction rates for C-H activation of 9-(4-X-phenyl)-9H-fluorene substrates by a transition metal catalyst. The equations generated throughout the study enable the prediction of Hammett parameters and relative reaction rates. These tools can accelerate synthetic and experimental studies by enabling the in silico prediction of uncharacterized chemical properties.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to use Loewdin atomic charges to predict experimental Hammett parameters and select relative reaction rates. Specifically, the research aims to evaluate the predictive ability of Loewdin atomic charges in three chemical systems:

1. **Prediction of Hammett parameters**: Predict experimental Hammett parameters (σp and σm) by generating univariate linear correlations using Loewdin atomic charges. The study found that Loewdin atomic charges are superior to Hirshfeld and CM5 charges in predicting Hammett parameters.

2. **Prediction of olefin cleavage reaction rates**: Evaluate the performance of Loewdin atomic charges in predicting relative reaction rates (log₁₀(krel)) through the cycloaddition reaction of photo - excited nitroarenes with model olefin substrates. The study found that Loewdin atomic charges perform well in most cases, but the correlation between the charge on the nitrogen atom and the relative reaction rate is poor. This situation can be improved by considering the net charge of the NO₂ group.

3. **Prediction of C - H activation reaction rates**: Evaluate the performance of Loewdin, Hirshfeld, and CM5 charges in predicting relative reaction rates through the C - H activation reaction of 9-(4 - X - phenyl)-9H - fluorene substrates by transition - metal catalysts. The study found that all three charge models perform well in generating correlations.

Overall, this paper demonstrates the potential of Loewdin atomic charges in predicting Hammett parameters and relative reaction rates through these studies, providing a powerful tool for synthetic and experimental research.