Abstract:Nonlinear dynamical systems exposed to changing forcing can exhibit catastrophic transitions between alternative and often markedly different states. The phenomenon of critical slowing down (CSD) can be used to anticipate such transitions if caused by a bifurcation and if the change in forcing is slow compared to the internal time scale of the system. However, in many real-world situations, these assumptions are not met and transitions can be triggered because the forcing exceeds a critical rate. For example, given the pace of anthropogenic climate change in comparison to the internal time scales of key Earth system components, such as the polar ice sheets or the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, such rate-induced tipping poses a severe risk. Moreover, depending on the realisation of random perturbations, some trajectories may transition across an unstable boundary, while others do not, even under the same forcing. CSD-based indicators generally cannot distinguish these cases of noise-induced tipping versus no tipping. This severely limits our ability to assess the risks of tipping, and to predict individual trajectories. To address this, we make a first attempt to develop a deep learning framework to predict transition probabilities of dynamical systems ahead of rate-induced transitions. Our method issues early warnings, as demonstrated on three prototypical systems for rate-induced tipping, subjected to time-varying equilibrium drift and noise perturbations. Exploiting explainable artificial intelligence methods, our framework captures the fingerprints necessary for early detection of rate-induced tipping, even in cases of long lead times. Our findings demonstrate the predictability of rate-induced and noise-induced tipping, advancing our ability to determine safe operating spaces for a broader class of dynamical systems than possible so far.

Tipping Prediction of a Class of Large-Scale Radial-Ring Neural Networks

Dynamical Bifurcation for a Class of Large-Scale Fractional Delayed Neural Networks With Complex Ring-Hub Structure and Hybrid Coupling

Bifurcation−Driven Tipping in A Novel Bicyclic Crossed Neural Network with Multiple Time Delays

Dynamical Bifurcation of Large-Scale-Delayed Fractional-Order Neural Networks with Hub Structure and Multiple Rings

Large-Scale Neural Networks with Asymmetrical Three-Ring Structure: Stability, Nonlinear Oscillations, and Hopf Bifurcation

Stability and Dynamics Analysis of Time-Delay Fractional-Order Large-Scale Dual-Loop Neural Network Model with Cross-Coupling Structure

Dynamics Analysis and Design for a Bidirectional Super-Ring-Shaped Neural Network with N Neurons and Multiple Delays.

Deep Learning for predicting rate-induced tipping

Analysis of Cyclic Dynamics for Networks of Linear Threshold Neurons.

Dynamics of tipping cascades on complex networks

Deep learning for predicting the occurrence of tipping points

Newton-Cotes Graph Neural Networks: on the Time Evolution of Dynamic Systems

Bifurcation and Oscillations of a Multi-ring Coupling Neural Network with Discrete Delays

Global Network Prediction from Local Node Dynamics

Extrapolating tipping points and simulating non-stationary dynamics of complex systems using efficient machine learning

Spatiotemporal Dynamics on a Class of (N+1)-Dimensional Reaction–diffusion Neural Networks with Discrete Delays and a Conical Structure

Dynamics of a Large-Scale Spiking Neural Network with Quadratic Integrate-and-Fire Neurons

Tipping Points of Evolving Epidemiological Networks: Machine Learning-Assisted, Data-Driven Effective Modeling

Tipping point for pulsatile oscillations in dynamical networks

Predicting Tipping Points in Mutualistic Networks Through Dimension Reduction