Abstract:Multiple regression analyses were performed on a worldwide 236—site data set compiled from studies that compared species composition, aboveground net primary production (ANPP), root biomass, and soil nutrients of grazed vs. protected, ungrazed sites. The objective was to quantitatively assess factors relating to differential sensitivities of ecosystems to grazing by large herbivores. A key question in this assessment was: Do empirically based, broad—scale relationships correspond to ecological theories of plant—animal interactions and conceptual frameworks for management of the world's grazing lands? Changes in species composition with grazing were primarily a function of ANPP and the evolutionary history of grazing of the site, with level of consumption third in importance. Changes in species composition increased with increasing productivity and with longer, more intense evolutionary histories of grazing. These three variables explained >50% of the variance in the species response of grasslands or grasslands—plus—shrublands to grazing, even though methods of measurement and grazing systems varied among studies. Years of protection from grazing was a significant variable only in the model for shrublands. Similar variables entered models of change in the dominant species with grazing. As with species composition, sensitivities of change in dominant species were greater to varying ecosystem—environmental variables than to varying grazing variables, from low to high values. Increase of the dominant species under grazing were predicted under some conditions, and decreases were more likely among bunch grasses than other life—forms and more likely among perennials than annuals. The response of shrublands was different from that of grasslands, both in terms of species composition and the dominant species. Our analyses support the perception of grazing as a factor in the conversion of grasslands to less desirable shrublands, but also suggest that we may be inadvertently grazing shrublands more intensively than grasslands. Percentage differences in ANPP between grazed and ungrazed sites decreased with increasingly long evolutionary histories of grazing and increased with increasing ANPP, levels of consumption, or years of treatment. Although most effects of grazing on ANPP were negative, some were not, and the statistical models predicted increases in ANPP with grazing under conditions of long evolutionary history, low consumption, few years of treatment, and low ANPP for grasslands—plus—shrublands. The data and the models support the controversial hypothesis that grazing can increase ANPP in some situations. Similar to species variables, percentage differences in ANPP between grazed and ungrazed treatments were more sensitive to varying ecosystem—environmental variables than to varying grazing variables. Within levels not considered to be abusive "overgrazing," the geographical location where grazing occurs may be more important than how many animals are grazed or how intensively an area is grazed. Counter to the commonly held view that grazing negatively impacts root systems, there was no relationship between difference in ANPP with grazing and difference in root mass; as many positive as negative differences occurred, even though most ANPP differences were negative. Further, there was a weak relationship between change in species composition and change in ANPP, and no relationship with root mass, soil organic matter, or soil nitrogen. All three belowground variables displayed both positive and negative values in response to grazing. Current management of much of the world's grazing lands based on species composition criteria may lead to erroneous conclusions concerning the long—term ability of a system to sustain productivity.

Author Response for "scale Dependence and Mechanisms of Grazing‐induced Biodiversity Changes Depend on Herbivore Type in Semiarid Grasslands"

Quantitative Effects of Grazing on Vegetation and Soils Over a Global Range of Environments

Scale-dependent patterns and mechanisms of grazing-induced biodiversity loss: evidence from a field manipulation experiment in semiarid steppe

Grazing Impairs Ecosystem Stability Through Changes in Species Asynchrony and Stability Rather Than Diversity Across Spatial Scales in Desert Steppe, Northern China

Effects of Grazing on Grassland Biomass and Biodiversity: A Global Synthesis

Grazing-induced Biodiversity Loss Impairs Grassland Ecosystem Stability at Multiple Scales

Effect of grazing and climatic factors on biodiversity-ecosystem functioning relationships in grassland ecosystems - a case study of typical steppe in Inner Mongolia, China

Grassland biodiversity response to livestock grazing, productivity, and climate varies across biome components and diversity measurements

Effects of Heavy Grazing on Interspecific Relationships at Different Spatial Scales in Desert Steppe of China

Scale effects on spatial heterogeneity of herbaceous vegetation in desert steppe depend on plant community type

Scale-Dependent Effects of Grazing on Plant C: N: P Stoichiometry and Linkages to Ecosystem Functioning in the Inner Mongolia Grassland

Effects of Grazing on Leaf Traits and Ecosystem Functioning in Inner Mongolia Grasslands: Scaling from Species to Community

Foraging selectivity of co-grazing cattle and sheep varies differently with plant diversity

Livestock Grazing Regulates Ecosystem Multifunctionality in Semi‐arid Grassland

Precipitation variation: a key factor regulating plant diversity in semi-arid livestock grazing lands

Grazing intensity affected spatial patterns of vegetation and soil fertility in a desert steppe

Effects of grazing on soil nitrogen spatial heterogeneity depend on herbivore assemblage and pre‐grazing plant diversity

Grazing Filtering Effect Based on Intraspecific and Interspecific Trait Variation and Its Scale Effects

The Response of Plant Alpha Diversity to Different Grazer Stocking Rate in a Stipa Breviflora.desert Steppe

Experimental impacts of grazing on grassland biodiversity and function are explained by aridity

Vertebrate herbivore-induced changes in plants and soils: linkages to ecosystem functioning in a semi-arid steppe