Abstract:Objective. Low-intensity transcranial ultrasound stimulation (TUS) is a promising non-invasive brain stimulation (NIBS) technique. TUS can reach deeper areas and target smaller regions in the brain than other NIBS techniques, but its application in humans is hampered by the lack of a straightforward and reliable procedure to predict the induced ultrasound exposure. Here, we examined how skull modeling affects computer simulations of TUS.Approach. We characterized the ultrasonic beam after transmission through a sheep skull with a hydrophone and performed computed tomography (CT) image-based simulations of the experimental setup. To study the skull model's impact, we varied: CT acquisition parameters (tube voltage, dose, filter sharpness), image interpolation, segmentation parameters, acoustic property maps (speed-of-sound, density, attenuation), and transducer-position mismatches. We compared the impact of modeling parameter changes on model predictions and on measurement agreement. Spatial-peak intensity and location, total power, and the Gamma metric (a measure for distribution differences) were used as quantitative criteria. Modeling-based sensitivity analysis was also performed for two human head models.Main results. Sheep skull attenuation assignment and transducer positioning had the most important impact on spatial peak intensity (overestimation up to 300%, respectively 30%), followed by filter sharpness and tube voltage (up to 20%), requiring calibration of the mapping functions. Positioning and skull-heterogeneity-structure strongly affected the intensity distribution (gamma tolerances exceeded in>80%, respectively>150%, of the focus-volume in water), necessitating image-based personalized modeling. Simulation results in human models consistently demonstrate a high sensitivity to the skull-heterogeneity model, attenuation tuning, and transducer shifts, the magnitude of which depends on the underlying skull structure complexity.Significance. Our study reveals the importance of properly modeling the skull-heterogeneity and its structure and of accurately reproducing the transducer position. The results raise red flags when translating modeling approaches among clinical sites without proper standardization and/or recalibration of the imaging and modeling parameters.

Transcranial ultrasound simulation with uncertainty estimation

Transcranial ultrasound simulations: a review

Accuracy of UTE-MRI-based patient setup for brain cancer radiation therapy.

High-Dimensional Uncertainty Quantification in Multi-Physics Simulation for 3D Large-Scale High-Power Microwave System

The impact of CT image parameters and skull heterogeneity modeling on the accuracy of transcranial focused ultrasound simulations

Classical and learned MR to pseudo-CT mappings for accurate transcranial ultrasound simulation

Performance of Learned Pseudo-Ct in Transcranial Ultrasound Simulations Using Fluid and Solid Skulls

Influence of shear waves on transcranial ultrasound propagation in cortical brain regions

Generating Patient-Specific Acoustic Simulations for Transcranial Focused Ultrasound Procedures Based on Optical Tracking Information

Numerical simulation of transcranial focused ultrasound therapy

Transcranial ultrasound estimation of viscoelasticity and fluidity in brain tumors aided by transcranial shear waves

Numerical Evaluation of the Influence of Skull Heterogeneity on Transcranial Ultrasonic Focusing

New semi-analytical method for fast transcranial ultrasonic field simulation

Uncertainty quantification of TMS simulations considering MRI segmentation errors

Pseudo-CTs from T1-weighted MRI for planning of low-intensity transcranial focused ultrasound neuromodulation: an open-source tool

A probabilistic approach to tomography and adjoint state methods, with an application to full waveform inversion in medical ultrasound

Benchmark problems for transcranial ultrasound simulation: Intercomparison of compressional wave models

A deep-learning model for one-shot transcranial ultrasound simulation and phase aberration correction

An Efficient Method for Transcranial Ultrasound Focus Correction Based on the Coupling of Boundary Integrals and Finite Elements.

Comparison Between Ray-Tracing and Full-Wave Simulation for Transcranial Ultrasound Focusing on a Clinical System Using the Transfer Matrix Formalism

Synthetic CT Skull Generation for Transcranial MR Imaging-Guided Focused Ultrasound Interventions with Conditional Adversarial Networks