On the Theoretical Quantification of Radii of Atoms in Molecules

Amin Alibakhshi,Lars V. Schäfer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-5qz9b-v2

2024-07-16

Abstract:Despite the fundamental importance of radii of atoms in molecules for numerous applications in physics and chemistry, comprehensive methods for their theoretical evaluation are still scarce. Here, we present quantum chemistry-based approaches for evaluation of radii of atoms in molecules and assess their robustness by studying the agreement of van der Waals and solvent-excluded surfaces constructed by them with reference molecular surfaces. By studying a large dataset of 1235 molecules, we show that estimation of radii via effective and free atomic volumes can accurately take the dependence of atomic radii on the chemical environment into account.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to accurately evaluate the atomic radii in molecules and their dependence on atomic partial charges. Specifically, the authors aim to develop and validate new methods for estimating the atomic radii in molecules and study the relationships between these radii and the chemical environment (especially atomic partial charges). The following are the main objectives and background of this study:

1. **Quantifying the atomic radii in molecules**:
- The traditional definitions of atomic radii have limitations when describing the interactions within molecules because they ignore the influence of the chemical environment.
- Researchers hope to evaluate atomic radii by introducing more dynamic methods, enabling them to better reflect the changes in different chemical environments.

2. **Atomic radii dependent on atomic partial charges**:
- The partial charge of an atom has a significant impact on its radius. For example, a positively charged ion appears smaller due to the stronger attraction of the nucleus to the outer - shell electrons, and vice versa.
- Researchers hope to reveal the precise relationship between atomic radii and partial charges to improve the understanding and modeling of intermolecular interactions.

3. **Constructing reliable molecular surface models**:
- Molecular surface models (such as van der Waals surfaces and solvent - excluded surfaces) are very important in theoretical chemistry, especially in the study of solvation effects.
- By optimizing atomic radii and applying them to the construction of molecular surfaces, researchers hope to improve the accuracy of these models.

### Main methods

- **Method based on isodensity surfaces**:
\[
R_A=\text{distance from the atomic nucleus to the isodensity surface}
\]
Use 0.0016 a.u. as the cutoff value of the isodensity surface.

- **Method based on effective volume**:
\[
R_A = R_{A,\text{free}}\left(\frac{V_A^{\text{eff}}}{V_A^{\text{free}}}\right)^{1/3}
\]
where,
\[
\frac{V_A^{\text{eff}}}{V_A^{\text{free}}}=\frac{\int w_A(\mathbf{r})n(\mathbf{r})d^3\mathbf{r}}{\int n_A^{\text{free}}(\mathbf{r})d^3\mathbf{r}}
\]
\(w_A\) is the weight function used to divide the molecular space into atomic sub - spaces, and \(R_{A,\text{free}}\) and \(n_A^{\text{free}}\) are the radius and electron density of atom A in the free state, respectively.

### Results and conclusions

- **Best match between SES surface and reference isodensity surface**:
- Using a probe radius of 0.4 Å, the mean unsigned percentage error (MUPE) between the SES surface and the reference isodensity surface is 1.31%, and the correlation coefficient is 0.9993.

- **Best performance of the Hirshfeld partitioning scheme**:
- The Hirshfeld partitioning method performs excellently in estimating the effective volume, and its optimized free - atom radii are highly consistent with the COSMO - RS parameterization results.

- **Linear relationship between atomic radii and partial charges**:
- There is an obvious linear relationship between the partial charges calculated using the iterative Hirshfeld (I - Hirshfeld) and MBIS partitioning methods and the atomic radii.

In conclusion, this study provides a reliable method for evaluating the atomic radii in molecules and reveals the relationships between these radii and partial charges, which is of great significance for understanding intermolecular interactions.