Medium-Density Amorphous Ice Unveils Shear Rate as a New Dimension in Water’s Phase Diagram

Valeria Molinero,Ingrid de Almeida Ribeiro,Debdas Dhabal,Rajat Kumar,Suvo Banik,Subramanian Sankaranarayanan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-7knv8
2024-07-03
Abstract:Recent experiments revealed a new amorphous ice phase, medium-density amorphous ice (MDA), formed by ball-milling ice Ih at 77 K (Rosu-Finsen et al., Science 2023, 379, 474-478). MDA has a density between that of low-density amorphous (LDA) and high-density amorphous (HDA) ice, adding to the complexity of water’s phase diagram, known for its glass polyamorphism and two-state thermody-namics. The nature of MDA and its relation to other amorphous ices and liquid water remain unsolved. Here, we use molecular simula-tions under controlled pressure and shear rate at 77 K to produce and investigate MDA. We find that MDA is not a nanocrystalline state but a shear-driven amorphous ice (SDA). Indeed, MDA formed at a constant shear rate is a non-equilibrium steady state that can be produced by shearing ice Ih, LDA, or HDA. These results suggest that MDA could be obtained by ball-milling water glasses. Increasing the shear rate produces SDAs with densities ranging from LDA to HDA at ambient pressure, revealing shear rate as a new thermodynamic variable in the non-equilibrium phase diagram of water. Shearing provides access to amorphous states that cannot be reached by control-ling pressure and temperature alone. However, SDAs and hyperquenched glasses with identical temperature, pressure, and density have indistinguishable energy and structure, suggesting a common potential energy landscape. Intriguingly, SDAs obtained by shearing at ~10^8 s⁻¹ have density, enthalpy, and structure indistinguishable from those of instantaneously quenched liquid water, indicating that shearing could render the “true glass” of ambient liquid water.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?