Microscopic pathways of transition from low-density to high-density amorphous phase of water

Gadha Ramesh,Ved Mahajan,Debasish Koner,Rakesh S. Singh
2024-02-27
Abstract:Much attention has been devoted to understanding the microscopic pathways of phase transition between two equilibrium condensed phases (such as liquids and solids). However, the microscopic pathways between non-equilibrium, non-diffusive amorphous (glassy) phases still remain poorly understood. In this work, we have employed computer simulations, persistence homology (a tool rooted in topological data analysis), and machine learning to probe the microscopic pathway of pressure-induced non-equilibrium transition between the low- and high-density amorphous (LDA and HDA, respectively) ice phases of TIP4P/2005 and ST2 water models. Using persistence homology and machine learning, we introduced a new order parameter that unambiguously identifies the LDA and HDA-like local environments. The system transitions continuously and collectively in the order parameter space via a pre-ordered intermediate phase during the compression of the LDA phase. The local order parameter susceptibilities show a maximum near the transition pressure ($P^*$) -- suggesting maximum structural heterogeneities near $P^*$. The HDA-like clusters are structurally ramified and spatially delocalized inside the LDA phase near the transition pressure. We have further investigated the (geometrical) structures and topologies of the LDA and HDA ices formed via different protocols and also studied the dependence of the microscopic pathway of phase transition in the order parameter space on the protocol followed to prepare the initial LDA phase. Finally, the method adopted here to study the microscopic pathways of transition is not restricted to the system under consideration and provides a robust way of probing phase transition pathways involving any two condensed phases at both equilibrium and out-of-equilibrium conditions.
Chemical Physics,Materials Science,Statistical Mechanics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems Addressed by the Paper This paper aims to investigate the microscopic transition pathways between Low-Density Amorphous (LDA) and High-Density Amorphous (HDA) water. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Microscopic Pathways of Non-Equilibrium Phase Transitions**: Although there has been considerable research on the phase transition pathways between liquid and solid states under equilibrium conditions, the microscopic pathways between non-equilibrium, non-diffusive amorphous (glassy) phases remain unclear. The paper explores the non-equilibrium transition pathways from LDA to HDA induced by pressure using computer simulations, Persistence Homology (a topological data analysis tool), and machine learning methods. 2. **New Order Parameter**: To more accurately identify the local environments of LDA and HDA, the paper introduces a new order parameter. This order parameter, based on persistence homology and machine learning techniques, can unambiguously identify the local structural characteristics of LDA and HDA. 3. **Structural Heterogeneity During Transition**: The paper analyzes the continuous and collective transitions in the order parameter space and finds that the susceptibility of the local order parameter reaches its maximum near the transition pressure, indicating the presence of maximum structural heterogeneity near this pressure. 4. **Structural Characteristics of HDA Clusters**: Near the transition pressure, HDA-like clusters exhibit structural branching and spatial delocalization within the LDA phase. 5. **Evidence of First-Order Liquid-Liquid Phase Transition**: The paper also explores the abrupt changes in the order parameter during the LDA to HDA transition, which is consistent with the theoretical predictions of a first-order low-density liquid to high-density liquid phase transition. 6. **Impact of Different Preparation Protocols**: The paper further investigates the impact of different protocols for preparing the initial LDA phase on the microscopic transition pathways, finding that the preparation protocol affects the system's transition pathways. In summary, this paper delves into the microscopic mechanisms of the LDA to HDA transition through a multidisciplinary approach, providing new insights into the properties of amorphous water.