Abstract:ABSTRACT The geodynamic origin of melting anomalies found at the surface, often referred to as “hotspots,” is classically attributed to a mantle plume process. The distribution of hotspots along mid-ocean-ridge spreading systems around the globe, however, questions the universal validity of this concept. Here, the preferential association of hotspots with slow- to intermediate-spreading centers and not fast-spreading centers, an observation contrary to the expected effect of ridge suction forces on upwelling mantle plumes, is explained by a new mechanism for producing melting anomalies at shallow (<2.3 GPa) depths. By combining the effects of both chemical and thermal density changes during partial melting of the mantle (using appropriate latent heat and depth-dependent thermal expansivity parameters), we find that mantle residues experience an overall instantaneous increase in density when melting occurs at <2.3 GPa. This controversial finding is due to thermal contraction of material during melting, which outweighs the chemical buoyancy due to melting at shallow pressures (where thermal expansivities are highest). These dense mantle residues are likely to locally sink beneath spreading centers if ridge suction forces are modest, thus driving an increase in the flow of fertile mantle through the melting window and increasing magmatic production. This leads us to question our understanding of sub–spreading center dynamics, where we now suggest a portion of locally inverted mantle flow results in hotspots. Such inverted flow presents an alternative mechanism to upwelling hot mantle plumes for the generation of excess melt at near-ridge hotspots, i.e., dense downwelling of mantle residue locally increasing the flow of fertile mantle through the melting window. Near-ridge hotspots, therefore, may not require the elevated temperatures commonly invoked to account for excess melting. The proposed mechanism also satisfies counterintuitive observations of ridge-bound hotspots at slow- to intermediate-spreading centers, yet not at fast-spreading centers, where large dynamic ridge suction forces likely overwhelm density-driven downwelling. The lack of observations of such downwelling in numerical modeling studies to date reflects the generally high chemical depletion buoyancy and/or low thermal expansivity parameter values employed in simulations, which we find to be unrepresentative for melting at <2.3 GPa. We therefore invite future studies to review the values used for parameters affecting density changes during melting (e.g., depletion buoyancy, latent heat of melting, specific heat capacity, thermal expansivity), which quite literally have the potential to turn our understanding of mantle dynamics upside down.

What Controls the Magma Production Rate along the Walvis Ridge, South Atlantic?

Mantle plume – mid ocean ridge interactions revealed from hotspot melt production rate along the Walvis Ridge-Rio Grande Rise

The upper-mantle density variation beneath the South Atlantic Ocean and its implications for hotspots and large igneous provinces

The crustal nature of the northern Mozambique Ridge, Southwest Indian Ocean

Magmato-tectonic Mechanism of Southwest Indian Ridge (49°-50°E) Inferred from Quantitative Morphotectonic Analysis Based on High-Resolution Multibeam Bathymetry

High sensitivity of ocean ridge thermal structure to changes in magma supply: the Galápagos Spreading Center

Magma Supply of the Southwest Indian Ocean : Evidence from Crustal Thickness Anomalies

Mid-Atlantic Ridge–Azores Hotspot Interactions: Along-Axis Migration of a Hotspot-Derived Event of Enhanced Magmatism 10 to 4 Ma Ago

Crustal Thickness of V‐shaped Ridges South of the Azores: Interaction of the Mid‐Atlantic Ridge (36°–39°N) and the Azores Hot Spot

Asymmetry of high-velocity lower crust on the South Atlantic rifted margins and implications for the interplay of magmatism and tectonics in continental breakup

A Compositional Anomaly at the Earth's Core–mantle Boundary As an Anchor to the Relatively Slowly Moving Surface Hotspots and As Source to the DUPAL Anomaly

Anomalously hot mantle source beneath the Dragon Flag Supersegment of the Southwest Indian Ridge: New evidence from crystallisation temperatures of mid-ocean ridge basalts

Volatiles beneath mid-ocean ridges: deep melting, channelised transport, focusing, and metasomatism

Trans‐Lithospheric Ascent Processes of the Deep‐Rooted Magma Plumbing System Underneath the Ultraslow‐Spreading SW Indian Ridge

Dense melt residues drive mid-ocean-ridge “hotspots”

Along-strike variation in volcanic addition controlling post-breakup sedimentary infill: Pelotas margin, austral South Atlantic

Effects of Hotspot‐Induced Long‐Wavelength Mantle Melting Variations on Magmatic Segmentation at the Reykjanes Ridge: Insights from 3D Geodynamic Modeling

The Reykjanes Ridge, North Atlantic

Highly variable magmatic accretion at the ultraslow-spreading Gakkel Ridge

Tectonic dismemberment and plume-ridge interaction in the Sub-Antarctic South Atlantic Ocean Basin: Confirmation from in situ geochemical and Sr isotopic compositions of minerals

Extreme Mantle Heterogeneity Revealed by Geochemical Investigation of In Situ Lavas at the Central Mohns Ridge, Arctic Mid‐Ocean Ridges