Abstract:Land policy making is a complex systemic process in which new policies emerge and are nonlinearly transferred. However, challenges remain, as the recent policy diffusion literature cannot match policy making to complex adaptive systems. This study elucidates the conjunctural causal mechanisms of local policy innovation and diffusion in China. To analyze the differences in China's land reform, a theoretical framework is established that includes four key conditions-incentive rules, local context, vertical governmental coercion and interregional diffusion-as well as three analytical principles, namely, nonlinearity, conjunction and intersection. Then, an archetype analysis based on the fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis method is conducted on 119 city governments that implemented land retention policies during the period of 2000-2019. The results systematically associate local policy action with five theory-based archetypes, each with its own narrative expression ("risk aversion", "reform pilot", "political learning", "induced competition", and "social evolution"). This article reveals that 1) China's administrative institutional structure shapes the reform motivation of local governments and their interaction with the central government, and the performance evaluation system for officials plays a key role in this dynamic; 2) local contexts can limit or amplify coercive and learning mechanisms, and policy knowledge can impede diffusion under certain conditions; and 3) the combination of archetypes occurs at three levels: theoretical mechanisms, conditional elements, and factor combinations. Overall, the study shows how multilevel factor interactions influence the decision-making process for China's land reform. These findings can serve as useful references for conjunctural causation research on policy innovation and diffusion in China and assist local decision makers in other countries in transition in developing sustainable land policies.

How Intermediate Government Facilitates Top-Down Policy Experimentation: Empirical Insights from Rural Land Marketization in Shanghai

District Government As a Policy Entrepreneur: Understanding Policy Experimentation in China's Wujin District

The Micro Administrative Mechanism of Land Reallocation in Land Consolidation: A Perspective from Collective Action

Decentralization, Local Information, and Effort Substitution: Evidence from a Subnational Decentralization Reform in China

Land Policy Making in a Complex System: the Innovation and Diffusion Logic of China's Retained Land Policy Reform

Local Government Competition and Centralised Urban Growth Management Policy Implementation: Evidence from China

Institutional conformity, entrepreneurial governance and local contingency: Problematizing central-local dynamics in localizing China's low-income housing policy

Experimentalist Governance with Interactive Central–Local Relations: Making New Pension Policies in China

A Study on Promoting the Intensive Use of Industrial Land in China Through Governance: A Game Theoretical Approach

Innovation or Implementation? Local Response to Low‐carbon Policy Experimentation in China

The Institutional Logic of the Evolution of Land Consolidation Policy in China:Analytical Framework and Historical Observation

Institutional Diversity or Isomorphism? Research on the Evolution of Collective-Owned Construction Land Marketization Reform since the 1990s—The Case of Shunde and Wujiang, China

Policy Experiments:Start -up Mechanisms and Internal Logic---Case Studies on the Performance Management Policies in China’s Public Sectors

The Dilemma of Land Expansion and Governance in Rural China: A Comparative Study Based on Three Townships in Zhejiang Province

Efficiency and Distribution of Rural Construction Land Marketization in Contemporary China

Policy Experimentation As Communication with the Public: Social Policy, Shared Responsibility and Regime Support in China

Experiment-based Policy Making or Conscious Policy Design? the Case of Urban Housing Reform in China

Rigidity with partial elasticity: Local government adaptation under the centralized land quota system in China

State-Firm Strategic Coordination and Technological Innovation in Shanghai and Shenzhen: A Comparative Study

Diffusion of Marketization Innovation with Administrative Centralization in a Multilevel System: Evidence from China

From Local Experiment to National Policy:Using the Rural Pension Policy as an Example