Abstract:Objective: To review the recently available interventions to achieve optimal visual clarity in laparoscopic abdominopelvic surgery compared to conventional cleaning alternatives. Currently, there is no consensus on the most effective method for the cleaning of endoscopic lenses used in minimally invasive abdominopelvic surgery. Methods: Literature searching for articles relevant to answering a predefined research question was performed in December 2019 and involved searching of the electronic databases of MEDLINE, the Cochrane Registry, and EMBASE. Basic search terms were derived using the PICO (population, intervention, comparator and outcomes) framework and through a scoping search of literature via MEDLINE. A manual search of Google Scholar and citation screening of eligible studies was also performed to ensure the identification and inclusion of all pertinent studies to address the research question. Results: Among conventional and readily available methods, the most effective approaches involved heated sterile water, heating of laparoscope lenses, and surfactant solutions, including FRED and Ultra-Stop, while evaluations of all novel devices and methods were more effective than controls, which included lens wiping systems and air and carbon dioxide flow systems. While the former surgical techniques were consistently associated with superior lens cleaning ability and/or defogging capability and subsequent optical clarity of images within the surgical field, no methods conferred any meaningful effects upon other clinically important outcomes, such as operative time, costs, complication rates and length of stay, suggesting that decision making concerning the selection of lens cleaning method/device should suit the preferences of the instrument operator and/or the responsible surgeon. Conclusions: We demonstrated that a range of endoscopic lens cleaning methods and devices can be used to achieve sufficient optical clarity of the laparoscopic surgical field through either preventing lenses from fogging and/or facilitating the inter-operative cleaning of fouled lenses. Despite the various methods evaluated in this review, there were no significant differences in complication rates between the intervention and control groups.

Quantitative assessment of the troCarWashTM system for automated laparoscopic camera cleaning

Design and Performance Testing of a Novel In Vivo Laparoscope Lens Cleaning Device

Catheter for Cleaning Surgical Optics During Surgical Procedures: A Possible Solution for Residue Buildup and Fogging in Video Surgery

Effective cleaning of endoscopic lenses to achieve visual clarity for minimally invasive abdominopelvic surgery: a systematic review

Efficacy of Using a Novel Endoscopic Lens Cleaning Device: A Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial

Surgical quality assessment of critical view of safety in 283 laparoscopic cholecystectomy videos by surgical residents and surgeons

Randomized controlled trial evaluating the effect of the use of a laparoscopic lens-cleaning device during laparoscopic colorectal surgery on the multidimensional workload (YCOG1903)

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy critical view of safety (LC-CVS): a multi-national validation study of an objective, procedure-specific assessment using video-based assessment (VBA)

Reliability of sensor-based real-time workflow recognition in laparoscopic cholecystectomy

Early Experience With a Novel Super-Hydrophilic Laparoscopic Scope Cleaning Device and Narrative Review of Available Cleaning Strategies

A multi-national, video-based qualitative study to refine training guidelines for assigning an "unsafe" score in laparoscopic cholecystectomy critical view of safety

A novel one-step lens cleaning device using air and water flow for endoscopic surgery

A novel, cost-effective lens irrigation system for rigid endoscopes in transnasal endoscopic surgery

Use of adenosine triphosphate to audit reprocessing of flexible endoscopes with an elevator mechanism

Assessment of endoscope cleaning and disinfection efficacy, and the impact of endoscope storage on the microbiological safety level

Cleaning Effects of New Cleaning Approaches for Flexible Endoscope

Detecting Contamination Events during Robotic Total Joint Arthroplasty

A New Irrigation System (Endosplash) for a Rigid Endoscope in Trans-sphenoidal Endoscopic Surgery

Quantification of surgical workflow during robotic proctectomy

An Accessible Laparoscope for Surgery in Low- and Middle- Income Countries

Role of dedicated port cleaning devices in laparoscopic surgery