Benchmarking Quantum Mechanical Levels of Theory for Valence Parametrization in Force Fields

Pavan Kumar Behara,Hyesu Jang,Joshua Horton,Trevor Gokey,David Dotson,Simon Boothroyd,Christopher Bayly,Daniel Cole,Lee-Ping Wang,David Mobley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-7sv95-v2
2024-02-26
Abstract:A wide range of density functional methods and basis sets are available to derive the electronic structure and properties of molecules. Quantum mechanical calculations are too computationally intensive for routine simulation of molecules in the condensed phase, prompting the development of computationally efficient force fields based on quantum mechanical data. Parametrizing general force fields, which cover a vast chemical space, necessitates generating sizable quantum mechanical datasets with optimized geometries and torsion scans. To achieve this efficiently, it is crucial to choose a quantum mechanical method that balances computational cost and accuracy. In this study we seek to assess the accuracy of quantum mechanical theory for specific properties such as conformer energies, electrostatic properties, and torsion energetics. To comprehensively evaluate various methods, we focus on a representative set of 59 diverse small molecules, comparing approximately 24 combinations of functional and basis sets against the reference level coupled cluster calculations at complete basis set limit.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main objective of this paper is to evaluate the accuracy and efficiency of different quantum mechanical methods in generating molecular datasets for force field parameterization. Specifically, the study focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Assessing the suitability of quantum mechanical methods**: Selecting a quantum mechanical method that needs to maintain high accuracy for various chemical properties and attributes globally, while being economically feasible in terms of computational cost. 2. **Benchmarking goals**: Evaluating the accuracy of approximately 24 functional and basis set combinations (including density functional theory methods and basis sets) against reference-level coupled-cluster calculations (CCSD(T)/CBS) for specific properties such as conformational energies, electrostatic properties, and torsional energetics. 3. **Selection of molecular samples**: To achieve the above goals, researchers selected 59 different small molecules for representative testing. These molecules cover a variety of element types and chemical characteristics within the drug-related chemical space, ensuring that the selected molecules adequately reflect common chemical environments in pharmaceutical research. 4. **Focus**: The study particularly focuses on the conformational energetics of small organic compounds, rather than long-range electrostatic interactions or other properties less relevant to drug design. 5. **Comparison standard**: The study uses DF-CCSD(T)/CBS//MP2/heavy-aug-cc-pVTZ as the reference level to evaluate the accuracy of various quantum mechanical methods, especially their performance in describing torsional energetic profiles. In summary, this paper aims to determine which quantum mechanical methods are most suitable for generating high-quality datasets to further develop general force fields, particularly for simulating the conformational behavior and energy trends of organic small molecules in pharmaceutical applications.