Abstract:Over the past decade, countries have strived to develop a global governance structure to halt deforestation and forest degradation, by achieving the readiness requirements for Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation (REDD+). Nonetheless, deforestation continues, and seemingly intact forest areas are being degraded. Furthermore, REDD+ may fail to consider the crucial ecosystem functions of forest fauna including seed dispersal and pollination. Throughout the tropics, forest animal populations are depleted by unsustainable hunting to the extent that many forests are increasingly devoid of larger mammals—a condition referred to as empty forests. Large mammals and birds, who often disperse seeds of larger more carbon-rich tree species, are preferentially targeted by hunters and the first to be depleted. Such defaunation has cascading ecosystem effects, changing forest structure and composition with implications for carbon storage capacity. Failure to address defaunation would therefore be a major oversight in REDD+, compromising its long-term viability. We carried out a desktop study reviewing REDD+ documents and national implementation efforts in Colombia, Ecuador, Nigeria, Tanzania, and Indonesia to assess the extent to which they address hunting and acknowledged the ecosystem functions of fauna. We also assessed sub-national REDD+ projects to determine whether they recognized hunting and if and how they incorporated hunting management and wildlife monitoring at the project level. Moreover, we assessed to what extent sub-national REDD+ projects addressed the long-term impacts of the sustainability of hunting on forest ecosystem function including carbon storage. We found that hunting, the risk of defaunation, and its effects have been ignored in the REDD+ policy process at both the international and national levels. At the project level, we found some reference to hunting and the risks posed by the loss of forest fauna, albeit only addressed superficially. Our results underline the fact that forest ecosystems are being reduced to their carbon content and that, despite the rhetoric of biodiversity co-benefits, fauna is not treated as a functional component of forests. This neglect threatens to undermine forest ecosystem function and service delivery as well as long-term forest carbon assimilation capacity and hence, ultimately, to compromise REDD+ objectives.

The Pet Trade's Role in Defaunation

The pet trade's role in defaunation.

Measuring the impact of the pet trade on Indonesian birds.

Drivers and spatial patterns of avian defaunation in tropical forests

Disproportionate regulation of wildlife trade

Local impact, global challenge: the role of domestic markets in the illegal wildlife trade

The ecological drivers and consequences of wildlife trade

Reflecting on the role of human‐felid conflict and local use in big cat trade

Ecological erosion of an Afrotropical forest and potential consequences for tree recruitment and forest biomass

Canada's role in global wildlife trade: Research trends and next steps

Impacts of hunting on tropical forests in Southeast Asia

Exposing illegal hunting and wildlife depletion in the world's largest tropical country through social media data

Perspectives on Conservation Impacts of the Global Primate Trade

Not Seeing the Forest for the Trees: The Oversight of Defaunation in REDD+ and Global Forest Governance

Bushmeat hunting, wildlife declines, and fish supply in West Africa

The wildlife snaring crisis: an insidious and pervasive threat to biodiversity in Southeast Asia

Wild-bird trade and exotic invasions: a new link of conservation concern?

A Snapshot of the Global Trade of South African Native Vertebrate Species Not Listed on CITES

Combating the exotic pet trade: Effects of conservation messaging on attitudes, demands, and civic intentions

The need for carbon finance schemes to tackle overexploitation of tropical forest wildlife