Evidence for $z_{c}^{\pm}$ Decays into the $\rho^{\pm} \eta_{c}$ Final State

M. Ablikim,М. Н. Ачасов,S. Ahmed,M. Albrecht,M. Alekseev,A. Amoroso,F. F. An,Q. An,Y. Bai,O. Bakina,R. Baldini Ferroli,Y. Ban,K. Begzsuren,D. W. Bennett,J. V. Bennett,N. Berger,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,F. Bianchi,E. Boger,I. Boyko,R. A. Briere,H. Cai,X. Cai,A. Calcaterra,G. F. Cao,S. A. Çetin,J. Chai,J. F. Chang,W. L. Chang,G. Chelkov,G. Chen,H. S. Chen,J. C. Chen,M. L. Chen,P. L. Chen,S. J. Chen,X. R. Chen,Y. B. Chen,Wei Cheng,X. Chu,G. Cibinetto,F. Cossio,H. L. Dai,J. P. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,D. Dedovich,Z. Y. Deng,A. Denig,I. Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. DeMori,Y. Ding,C. Dong,J. Dong,Dong Liu,M. Y. Dong,Z. L. Dou,S. X. Du,Pengfei Duan,J. Fang,S. S. Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Q. Feng,M. Fritsch,C. D. Fu,Q. Gao,X. L. Gao,Y. S. Gao,Y. Gao,Z. Gao,B. Garillon,I. Garzia,A. Gilman,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. X. Gong,W. Gradl,M. Greco,L. Gu,M. H. Gu,Y. T. Gu,A. Q. Guo,Linghua Guo,R. P. Guo,Y. P. Guo,A. Guskov,Z. Haddadi,S. Han,X. Q. Hao,F. A. Harris,K. L. He,F. H. Heinsius,T. Held,Y. K. Heng,Z. L. Hou,H. M. Hu,Jifeng Hu,T. Hu,Yiming Hu,G. S. Huang,J. Huang,X. T. Huang,X. Z. Huang,Zhengwen Huang,T. Hussain,W. Ikegami Andersson,M. Irshad,Q. Ji,Q. P. Ji,X. B. Ji,X. L. Ji,H. L. Jiang,X. S. Jiang,X. Y. Jiang,J. B. Jiao,Jiao Zhang,D. P. Jin,S. Jin,Yanling Jin,T. Johansson,A. Julin,N. Kalantar–Nayestanaki,X. S. Kang,M. Kavatsyuk,B. C. Ke,I. K. Keshk,Tabassum Khan,A. Khoukaz,P. Kiese,R. Kiuchi,R. Kliemt,L. Koch,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kuemmel,M. Kuessner,A. Kupść,Matthew Glenn Kurth,W. Kühn,J. S. Lange,P. Larin,L. Lavezzi,S. Leiber,H. Leithoff,C. Li,Cheng Li,D. M. Li,F. Li,F. Y. Li,G. Li,H. B. Li,H. J. Li,J. C. Li,J. W. Li,K. J. Li,Kang Li,Ké Li,Lei Li,Pinrui Li,P. R. Li,Q. Y. Li,T. Li,W. D. Li,W. G. Li,X. L. Li,X. N. Li,X. Q. Li,Z. B. Li,H. Liang,Y. F. Liang,Y. T. Liang,G. R. Liao,L. Z. Liao,J. Libby,C. X. Lin,D. X. Lin,B. Liu,B. J. Liu,C. X. Liu,D. Liu,D. Y. Liu,F. H. Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,H. B. Liu,H. L. Liu,H. M. Liu,Huanhuan Liu,Huihui Liu,J. B. Liu,J. Y. Liu,K. Y. Liu,Ke Liu,L. D. Liu,Q. Liu,S. B. Liu,X. Liu,Y. B. Liu,Z. A. Liu,Zhiqing Liu,Y. F. Long,X. C. Lou,H. Lu,J. G. Lu,Y. P. Lu,C. L. Luo,M. X. Luo,P. W. Luo,T. Luo,X. L. Luo,S. Lusso,Xudong Lyu,F. C.,H. L.,L. L.,M. M.,Q. M.,X. N.,X. Y.,Y. M.,F. E. Maas,M. Maggiora,S. Maldaner,Q. A. Malik,A. Mangoni,Y. J. Mao,Z. P. Mao,S. Marcello,Z. Meng,J. G. Messchendorp,G. Mezzadri,J. Min,T. J. Min,R. E. Mitchell,X. H. Mo,Y. J. Mo,Morales,N. Yu. Muchnoi,H. Muramatsu,A. Mustafa,S. Nakhoul,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. B. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,S. L. Niu,X. Y. Niu,S. L. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,Y. Pan,M. Papenbrock,P. Patteri,M. Pelizaeus,J. Pellegrino,H. P. Peng,Z. Y. Peng,K. Peters,J. Pettersson,J. L. Ping,R. G. Ping,A. Pitka,R. Poling,V. Prasad,H. R. Qi,M. Qi,T. Y. Qi,S. Qian,C. F. Qiao,N. Qin,X. S. Qin,Z. H. Qin,J. F. Qiu,S. Q. Qu,K. H. Rashid,C. F. Redmer,M. Richter,M. Ripka,A. Rivetti,M. Rolo,G. Rong,Ch. Rosner,A. Sarantsev,M. Savrié,K. Schoenning,W. Shan,X. Y. Shan,M. Shao,C. P. Shen,P. X. Shen,X. Y. Shen,H. Y. Sheng,X. Shi,J. J. Song,W. M. Song,X. Y. Song,S. Sosio,C. Sowa,S. Spataro,F. F. Sui,G. X. Sun,J. F. Sun,L. Sun,S. S. Sun,X. H. Sun,Y. J. Sun,Y. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Z. J. Sun,Z. T. Sun,Y. T. Tan,C. J. Tang,G. Y. Tang,Xiao Tang,M. Tiemens,B. Tsednee,I. Uman,B. Wang,B. L. Wang,C. W. Wang,D. Wang,D. Y. Wang,Dan Wang,H. H. Wang,K. Wang,L. L. Wang,L. S. Wang,M. Wang,Meng Wang,P. Wang,P. L. Wang,W. P. Wang,X. F. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. F. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. G. Wang,Z. Y. Wang,Zongyuan Wang,T. Weber,D. H. Wei,P. Weidenkaff,S. P. Wen,U. Wiedner,M. Wolke,L. H. Wu,L. J. Wu,Zhi Wang,Lei Xia,X. M. Xia,Y. Xia,D. Xiao,Yunlong Xiao,Z. J. Xiao,Y. G. Xie,Y. Xie,X. A. Xiong,Q. L. Xiu,G. F. Xu,Jingjing Xu,Lei Xu,Q. J. Xu,Xiaolong Xu,F. Yan,L. Yan,W. B. Yan,W. C. Yan,Y. H. Yan,H. Yang,H. X. Yang,Lei Yang,R. X. Yang,S. Yang,Yifan Yang,Youhua Yang,Zhi Yang,M. Ye,M. H. Ye,J. H. Yin,Z. Y. You,B. X. Yu,C. X. Yu,J. S. Yu,C. Z. Yuan,Y. Yuan,A. Yuncu,A. A. Zafar,Yun Zeng,B. X. Zhang,B. Y. Zhang,C. C. Zhang,D. H. Zhang,H. H. Zhang,H. Y. Zhang,J. Zhang,J. L. Zhang,J. Q. Zhang,J. W. Zhang,J. Y. Zhang,J. Z. Zhang,K. Zhang,L. Zhang,S. F. Zhang,Tianyu Zhang,X. Y. Zhang,Yue Zhang,Y. H. Zhang,Y. T. Zhang,Yang Zhang,YaoZ hang,Yu Zhang,Z. H. Zhang,Z. P. Zhang,Z. Y. Zhang,Gang Zhao,Jiawei Zhao,J. Y. Zhao,J. Z. Zhao,Zhao Liu,Ling Zhao,Mingmin Zhao,Q. Zhao,Shu-Min Zhao,T. Zhao,Y. B. Zhao,Z. G. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. P. Zheng,W. J. Zheng,Y. Zheng,B. Zhong,L. Zhou,Q. Zhou,X. Y. Zhou,X. Zhou,X. R. Zhou,Xingyu Zhou,X. K. Zhou,A. N. Zhu,J. Zhu,K. Zhu,S. H. Zhu,Xianglei Zhu,Y. C. Zhu,Y. S. Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,J. Zhuang,Bingsuo Zou,J. H. Zou

IF: 5.407

2019-01-01

Physical Review D

Abstract:We study $e^{+}e^{-}$ collisions with a $\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\eta_{c}$ final state using data samples collected with the BESIII detector at center-of-mass energies $\sqrt{s}=4.226$, $4.258$, $4.358$, $4.416$, and $4.600$ GeV. Evidence for the decay $\zcpm\to\rhopm\etac$ is reported with a statistical significance of $3.9\sigma$ with various systematic uncertainties taken into account at $\sqrt{s} = 4.226$ GeV, and the Born cross section times branching fraction $\sigma^{B}(\EE\to \pimp\zcpm)\times \BR(\zcpm\to\rhopm\etac)$ is measured to be $(48 \pm 11 \pm 11)\,\rm{pb}$. The $\zcpm\to \rhopm\etac$ signal is not significant at the other center-of-mass energies and the corresponding upper limits are determined. In addition, no significant signal is observed in a search for $\zcppm\to \rho^{\pm}\etac$ with the same data samples. The ratios $R_{\zc}=\BR(\zcpm\to \rho^{\pm} \etac)/\BR(\zcpm\to \pi^{\pm} \jpsi)$ and $R_{\zcp}=\BR(\zcppm\to \rho^{\pm} \etac)/\BR(\zcppm\to \pi^{\pm} \hc)$ are obtained and used to discriminate between different theoretical interpretations of the $\zcpm$ and $\zcppm$.