Observation and Study of the Decay J/ψ→ϕηη′

M. Ablikim,M. N. Achasov,S. Ahmed,M. Albrecht,M. Alekseev,A. Amoroso,F. F. An,Q. An,J. Z. Bai,Y. Bai,O. Bakina,R. Baldini Ferroli,Y. Ban,K. Begzsuren,D. W. Bennett,J. Bennett,N. Berger,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,F. Bianchi,E. Boger,I Boyko,R. A. Briere,H. Cai,X. Cai,O. Cakir,A. Calcaterra,G. F. Cao,S. A. Cetin,J. Chai,J. F. Chang,G. Chelkov,G. Chen,H. S. Chen,J. C. Chen,M. L. Chen,P. L. Chen,S. J. Chen,X. R. Chen,Y. B. Chen,W. Cheng,X. K. Chu,G. Cibinetto,F. Cossio,H. L. Dai,J. P. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,D. Dedovich,Z. Y. Deng,A. Denig,I Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. De Mori,Y. Ding,C. Dong,J. Dong,L. Y. Dong,M. Y. Dong,Z. L. Dou,S. X. Du,P. F. Duan,J. Fang,S. S. Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,S. Fegan,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Q. Feng,E. Fioravanti,M. Fritsch,C. D. Fu,Q. Gao,X. L. Gao,Y. Gao,Y. G. Gao,Z. Gao,B. Garillon,I Garzia,A. Gilman,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. X. Gong,W. Gradl,M. Greco,M. H. Gu,Y. T. Gu,A. Q. Guo,R. P. Guo,Y. P. Guo,A. Guskov,Z. Haddadi,S. Han,X. Q. Hao,F. A. Harris,K. L. He,X. Q. He,F. H. Heinsius,T. Held,Y. K. Heng,Z. L. Hou,H. M. Hu,J. F. Hu,T. Hu,Y. Hu,G. S. Huang,J. S. Huang,X. T. Huang,X. Z. Huang,Z. L. Huang,T. Hussain,W. Ikegami Andersson,M. Irshad,Q. Ji,Q. P. Ji,X. B. Ji,X. L. Ji,X. S. Jiang,X. Y. Jiang,J. B. Jiao,Z. Jiao,D. P. Jin,S. Jin,Y. Jin,T. Johansson,A. Julin,N. Kalantar-Nayestanaki,X. S. Kang,M. Kavatsyuk,B. C. Ke,I. K. Keshk,T. Khan,A. Khoukaz,P. Kiese,R. Kiuchi,R. Kliemt,L. Koch,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kornicer,M. Kuemmel,M. Kuessner,A. Kupsc,M. Kurth,W. Kuehn,J. S. Lange,P. Larin,L. Lavezzi,H. Leithoff,C. Li,Cheng Li,D. M. Li,F. Li,F. Y. Li,G. Li,H. B. Li,H. J. Li,J. C. Li,J. W. Li,Jin Li,K. J. Li,Kang Li,Ke Li,Lei Li,P. L. Li,P. R. Li,Q. Y. Li,W. D. Li,W. G. Li,X. L. Li,X. N. Li,X. Q. Li,Z. B. Li,H. Liang,Y. F. Liang,Y. T. Liang,G. R. Liao,L. Z. Liao,J. Libby,C. X. Lin,D. X. Lin,B. Liu,B. J. Liu,C. X. Liu,D. Liu,D. Y. Liu,F. H. Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,H. B. Liu,H. L. Liu,H. M. Liu,Huanhuan Liu,Huihui Liu,J. B. Liu,J. Y. Liu,K. Liu,K. Y. Liu,Ke Liu,L. D. Liu,Q. Liu,S. B. Liu,X. Liu,Y. B. Liu,Z. A. Liu,Zhiqing Liu,Y. F. Long,X. C. Lou,H. J. Lu,J. G. Lu,Y. Lu,Y. P. Lu,C. L. Luo,M. X. Luo,T. Luo,X. L. Luo,S. Lusso,X. R. Lyu,F. C. Ma,H. L. Ma,L. L. Ma,M. M. Ma,Q. M. Ma,T. Ma,X. N. Ma,X. Y. Ma,Y. M. Ma,F. E. Maas,M. Maggiora,S. Maldaner,Q. A. Malik,A. Mangoni,Y. J. Mao,Z. P. Mao,S. Marcello,Z. X. Meng,J. G. Messchendorp,G. Mezzadri,J. Min,R. E. Mitchell,X. H. Mo,Y. J. Mo,Morales,N. Yu Muchnoi,H. Muramatsu,A. Mustafa,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. B. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,S. L. Niu,X. Y. Niu,S. L. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,Y. Pan,M. Papenbrock,P. Patteri,M. Pelizaeus,J. Pellegrino,H. P. Peng,Z. Y. Peng,K. Peters,J. Pettersson,J. L. Ping,R. G. Ping,A. Pitka,R. Poling,V Prasad,H. R. Qi,M. Qi,T. Y. Qi,S. Qian,C. F. Qiao,N. Qin,X. S. Qin,Z. H. Qin,J. F. Qiu,S. Q. Qu,K. H. Rashid,C. F. Redmer,M. Richter,M. Ripka,A. Rivetti,M. Rolo,G. Rong,Ch Rosner,A. Sarantsev,M. Savrie,K. Schoenning,W. Shan,X. Y. Shan,M. Shao,C. P. Shen,P. X. Shen,X. Y. Shen,H. Y. Sheng,X. Shi,J. J. Song,W. M. Song,X. Y. Song,S. Sosio,C. Sowa,S. Spataro,G. X. Sun,J. F. Sun,L. Sun,S. S. Sun,X. H. Sun,Y. J. Sun,Y. K. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Z. J. Sun,Z. T. Sun,Y. T. Tan,C. J. Tang,G. Y. Tang,X. Tang,I Tapan,M. Tiemens,B. Tsednee,I Uman,B. Wang,B. L. Wang,D. Wang,D. Y. Wang,Dan Wang,K. Wang,L. L. Wang,L. S. Wang,M. Wang,Meng Wang,P. Wang,P. L. Wang,W. P. Wang,X. F. Wang,X. L. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. F. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. G. Wang,Z. Y. Wang,Zongyuan Wang,T. Weber,D. H. Wei,P. Weidenkaff,S. P. Wen,U. Wiedner,M. Wolke,L. H. Wu,L. J. Wu,Z. Wu,L. Xia,Y. Xia,D. Xiao,Y. J. Xiao,Z. J. Xiao,Y. G. Xie,Y. H. Xie,X. A. Xiong,Q. L. Xiu,G. F. Xu,J. J. Xu,L. Xu,Q. J. Xu,Q. N. Xu,X. P. Xu,F. Yan,L. Yan,W. B. Yan,W. C. Yan,Y. H. Yan,H. J. Yang,H. X. Yang,L. Yang,R. X. Yang,Y. H. Yang,Y. X. Yang,Yifan Yang,Z. Q. Yang,M. Ye,M. H. Ye,J. H. Yin,Z. Y. You,B. X. Yu,C. X. Yu,J. S. Yu,C. Z. Yuan,Y. Yuan,A. Yuncu,A. A. Zafar,Y. Zeng,B. X. Zhang,B. Y. Zhang,C. C. Zhang,D. H. Zhang,H. H. Zhang,H. Y. Zhang,J. Zhang,J. L. Zhang,J. Q. Zhang,J. W. Zhang,J. Y. Zhang,J. Z. Zhang,K. Zhang,L. Zhang,T. J. Zhang,X. Y. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. H. Zhang,Y. T. Zhang,Yang Zhang,Yao Zhang,Yi Zhang,Yu Zhang,Z. H. Zhang,Z. P. Zhang,Z. Y. Zhang,G. Zhao,J. W. Zhao,J. Y. Zhao,J. Z. Zhao,Lei Zhao,Ling Zhao,M. G. Zhao,Q. Zhao,S. J. Zhao,T. C. Zhao,Y. B. Zhao,Z. G. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. P. Zheng,Y. H. Zheng,B. Zhong,L. Zhou,Q. Zhou,X. Zhou,X. K. Zhou,X. R. Zhou,X. Y. Zhou,Xiaoyu Zhou,Xu Zhou,A. N. Zhu,J. Zhu,K. Zhu,K. J. Zhu,S. Zhu,S. H. Zhu,X. L. Zhu,Y. C. Zhu,Y. S. Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,J. Zhuang,B. S. Zou,J. H. Zou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.99.112008

2019-01-01

Abstract:We report the observation and study of the decay $J/\psi\rightarrow\phi\eta\eta'$ using $1.3\times{10^9}$ $J/\psi$ events collected with the BESIII detector. Its branching fraction, including all possible intermediate states, is measured to be $(2.32\pm0.06\pm0.16)\times{10^{-4}}$. We also report evidence for a structure, denoted as $X$, in the $\phi\eta'$ mass spectrum in the $2.0-2.1$ GeV/$c^2$ region. Using two decay modes of the $\eta'$ meson ($\gamma\pi^+\pi^-$ and $\eta\pi^+\pi^-$), a simultaneous fit to the $\phi\eta'$ mass spectra is performed. Assuming the quantum numbers of the $X$ to be $J^P = 1^-$, its significance is found to be 4.4$\sigma$, with a mass and width of $(2002.1 \pm 27.5 \pm 21.4)$ MeV/$c^2$ and $(129 \pm 17 \pm 9)$ MeV, respectively, and a product branching fraction $\mathcal{B}(J/\psi\rightarrow\eta{}X)\times{}\mathcal{B}(X\rightarrow\phi\eta')=(9.8 \pm 1.2 \pm 1.7)\times10^{-5}$. Alternatively, assuming $J^P = 1^+$, the significance is 3.8$\sigma$, with a mass and width of $(2062.8 \pm 13.1 \pm 7.2)$ MeV/$c^2$ and $(177 \pm 36 \pm 35)$ MeV, respectively, and a product branching fraction $\mathcal{B}(J/\psi\rightarrow\eta{}X)\times{}\mathcal{B}(X\rightarrow\phi\eta')=(9.6 \pm 1.4 \pm 2.0)\times10^{-5}$. The angular distribution of $J/\psi\rightarrow\eta{}X$ is studied and the two $J^P$ assumptions of the $X$ cannot be clearly distinguished due to the limited statistics. In all measurements the first uncertainties are statistical and the second systematic.