Abstract:The overall goal of our article is to better understand which matters for water savings, farmer income and poverty in China's irrigation systems: incentives to managers or participation of farmers. To pursue this goal, the article has three objectives. First, we track the evolution of water management reform, examining the practice of providing incentives to managers, and increasing the participation of farmers. Second, we identify the impact of water management reform on crop water use. Specifically, we want to measure whether or not incentives to managers and farmer participation in water management institutions affect the performance of the irrigation system. Because we also are interested in the potential results of water management reform, the article explores how changes in incentives and farmer participation affect farmer income and poverty. Based on a random sample of 51 villages and 189 farmers in four large irrigation districts in Ningxia and Henan provinces, both in China's Yellow River Basin, our results show that the two major forms of water management reform, water users' associations (WUAs) and contracting, have begun to systematically replace traditional forms of collective management. Our analysis demonstrates, however, that it is not the nominal implementation of the reform that matters, but rather it is the creation of new management institutions that offer water managers monetary incentives that lead to water savings. In contrast to the original design of China's reform policies, participation of farmers has not played a role in saving water. Importantly, given China's concerns about national food production and poverty alleviation, the reductions in water, at least in our sample sites, do not lead to reductions in income and do not increase the incidence of poverty.

Making Irrigation Management Pro-Poor: Lessons from China and Vietnam

How physical and social factors affect village-level irrigation: An institutional analysis of water governance in northern China

Irrigation Management Reforms in the Yellow River Basin: Implications for Water Saving and Poverty

Irrigation, Agricultural Performance and Poverty Reduction in China

Improving Water Management Practices to Reduce Nutrient Export from Rice Paddy Fields

Incentives to Managers or Participation of Farmers in China'S Irrigation Systems: Which Matters Most for Water Savings, Farmer Income, and Poverty?

Improving performance and financial viability of irrigation systems in India and China

Water Management Reform,Agricultural Production,and Poverty Reduction

Irrigation, Poverty and Inequality in Rural China

Issues On Management Transfer Over Irrigation Infrastructure In China

Irrigation Management in East Asia: Institutions, Socio-Economic Transformation and Adaptations

Forty Years of Irrigation Development and Reform in China

The Positive Impacts of Irrigation Schedules on Rice Yield and Water Consumption: Synergies in Jilin Province, Northeast China

Incentives in Water Management Reform: Assessing the Effect on Water Use, Production, and Poverty in the Yellow River Basin

Irrigation for poverty alleviation

Success Factors of Irrigation Projects Based on A "Public–Private Partnership" Model in A Mountainous Area: A Case Study in the Nujiang River Valley, China

Institutional Reform and Impacts: the Case Study in the Yellow River Basin

Empirical Assessment of Water Management Institutions in Northern China

Internet Access and Irrigation Adoption in China

Improvement of the Irrigation Scheme in the ORCHIDEE Land Surface Model and Impacts of Irrigation on Regional Water Budgets over China

An Empirical Examination on the Role of Water User Associations for Irrigation Management in Rural China