Abstract:Due to the frequent irrigation and excessive fertilization during the rice production in China, diffuse nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) pollution from paddy fields has become a serious environment problem and poses great challenges to national water and food security. Considering the regional heterogeneities of climate, cultivation types and cropping systems of rice planting, many water management strategies have been proposed and implemented to control diffuse N and P pollution. However, the water management optimization at different scales (the field scale, the watershed scale and national scale) is lack of comprehensive analyzed. Here, this paper summarized the characteristics of frequent-used water managements and recommended the optimal water managements after identifying the critical risk periods of diffuse N and P runoff losses at the field scale. The effects of water management optimization on diffuse N and P pollution control at the watershed and national scale were also synthetically reviewed. The results indicated that optimized field water management decreased irrigation water use (38.7–40.0%) and reduced diffuse pollution (25.5–38.8%) without significantly compromising rice yield security (−4.20 to 6.5%). The critical risk periods of diffuse pollution were pre-flooding in the Northeast Plain, pre-flooding, regreening stage for transplanting rice (the seeding-three leaf stage for direct seeding rice) and within 2 weeks after topdressing fertilization in the Yangtze River Basin and Southeast Coast in China. The corresponding water managements for these periods has been proposed after considering the climate, precipitation and fertilization characteristics. Ditches and ponds intercepted water and nutrients and mitigated 6.0–39.0% N and P runoff losses in paddy field watersheds. Furthermore, the extensive implementation of paddy water management optimization (paddy fields, ditches and ponds) combined with other advanced agricultural measures, for example, fertilization optimization, would decrease diffuse N and P pollution by 40.7–80.8% at the watershed scale and 44.7–88.1% at the national scale, respectively. This research provided great insights into the specific characteristics of paddy water managements from the fields, watershed and national scale, proposed optimal water management strategies for the realization of sustainable rice production in China, and also summarized the emerging development trends for future research directions.

Improving Water Management Practices to Reduce Nutrient Export from Rice Paddy Fields

Effects of Water Management Patterns and Nitrogen Fertilizer Levels on Nitrogen Use Efficiency of Rice

Combining Alternate Wetting and Drying Irrigation with Reduced Phosphorus Fertilizer Application Reduces Water Use and Promotes Phosphorus Use Efficiency Without Yield Loss in Rice Plants

Exploring Optimal Nitrogen Management Strategies to Mitigate Nitrogen Losses from Paddy Soil in the Middle Reaches of the Yangtze River

Mitigation of nutrient losses via surface runoff from rice cropping systems with alternate wetting and drying irrigation and site-specific nutrient management practices

Controlled Irrigation and Drainage Reduce Rainfall Runoff and Nitrogen Loss in Paddy Fields

Paddy Water Managements for Diffuse Nitrogen and Phosphorus Pollution Control in China: A Comprehensive Review and Emerging Prospects

Water-saving irrigation practices for rice yield information and nitrogen use efficiency under sub-tropical monsoon climate

Nationwide Estimates of Nitrogen and Phosphorus Losses Via Runoff from Rice Paddies Using Data-Constrained Model Simulations

Increasing water productivity, nitrogen economy, and grain yield of rice by water saving irrigation and fertilizer-N management

Declines in Nutrient Losses from China's Rice Paddies Jointly Driven by Fertilizer Application and Extreme Rainfall

Potential Nutrient Removal Function of Naturally Existed Ditches and Ponds in Paddy Regions: Prospect of Enhancing Water Quality by Irrigation and Drainage Management

Impact of reduced fertilizer application on the yield and non-point source pollution from Yongyou rice cultivation

Subsurface Fluxes Dominate the Dissolved Nitrogen Losses from Rice Paddies in Central China

Optimal fertilizer rates towards the improvement of nitrogen use efficiency and reduction of nitrogen export in paddy rice-wheat intensive farming

Higher Rice Productivity and Lower Paddy Nitrogen Loss with Optimized Irrigation and Fertilization Practices in a Rice-Upland System

Reducing environmental risk by improving N management in intensive Chinese agricultural systems

Improved estimation of nitrogen dynamics in paddy surface water in China

Annual greenhouse gas emissions from a rice paddy with different water-nitrogen management strategies in Central China

A Gis-Based Upscaling Estimation Of Nutrient Runoff Losses From Rice Paddy Fields To A Regional Level

No-tillage Effects on N and P Exports Across a Rice-Planted Watershed