Is the Offsetting Effect of Trade Credits on Bank Credits Counter-Cyclic? Evidence from China

Shen Xiao-jun,Z Shunming,Jie Long
2010-01-01
Abstract:This paper seeks to find empirical evidence of trade credits' offsetting effects on bank credits in China,and to describe the behavior of this effect through contracting and expanding business cycles. Using a panel dataset of 284 China's listed companies covering the period 1998 to 2006,we estimate random-effect panel models with time-invariant and time-varying coefficients. Estimation results show that the average substitution ratio between trade credits and bank loans is about 17.2%,which provides supporting evidence for the offsetting effect. However,this effect decreases to 8.8% in the dynamic panel model that is purposefully designed to incorporate the lagged effect of trade credits. Furthermore,we find solid evidence on the counter-cyclic behavior of the offsetting effect by applying a ROC test and estimating another dynamic panel model with cross-terms of business cycle indicators. Robustness analysis based on different industrial sub-samples also provides supporting evidence for the offsetting effect and its counter-cyclic behavior.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?