Can Trade Credit Help Enterprises to Survive the Financial Crisis
Zhu-quan WANG,Shi-yun ZHAI,Zhen-jie WANG
2014-01-01
Abstract:The explosion of 2008 global financial crisis brought great damage to the world's economy,during which not only did consumption decrease and bad debts increase in commodity market,but also bank loan standard was raised and investment scale by shareholders was deducted in capital market.In such desperation,many enterprises turned to trade credit for silver lining,by attempting to gain as much trade credit as they can to obtain more abundant liquidity,thus reducing their financial risks.But would it really work? Using a sample of empirical data from 2004 to 2012 of A-share listed companies in China,this paper tends to analyze the impact the crisis had on said companies.We sorted year 2008 ~ 2012 as the financial crisis period since it appeared to suffer more explicit damage through analysis.We will be focusing on how trade credit reacted to financial crisis,and how Financing Theory would explain the situation.Moreover,based on previous researches,we come up with a more comprehensive definition method for trade credit.Meanwhile,the paper innovatively takes a peek at the relationship between trade credit and property rights.The study ends up with a series of constructive conclusions.Firstly,during financial crisis,the market worried about the solvency of financial institutions,reluctant to provide financing,resulting in Banks' liquidity shortage.At the same time,product sales went through serious difficulties and profit dropped sharply,leading to massive deduction,restructuring and bankruptcy of enterprises,which was a concern for banks surely.As fear of crisis spread,lack of liquidity became the main factors of financial markets,causing banks to raise loan threshold.Chinese listed companies could barely get enough bank loans and the situation was worsening as the crisis deepened.Secondly,as the impact of financial crisis continued to deteriorate,companies' net trade credit reduced instead.During financial crisis,many enterprises were on the brink of bankruptcy,needing of survival coming before making profit,which left ample liquidity becoming the most important issue.Therefore,enterprises tend to try every means to maximize their net trade credit.However,in the period of financial crisis,money was quite tight for most companies,especially for small companies.Besides,companies of higher debt ratio,lower return on assets,less cash holdings,and less cash flow tend to face greater financial risk.Although the demand for trade credit should be more urgent in less performed companies,their customers and suppliers were relatively pessimistic about their prospects and financial crisis would further accelerate this pessimism,making it harder for said companies to gain trade credit.As we all know,State-owned companies usually have strong anti-risk and solvency guaranteed abilities.Undoubtedly,creditors would prefer stateowned companies to non-state-owned ones when it comes to offering trade credit help,which means that non-stateowned companies were left with less and less trade credit.Finally,bank loans and trade credit are two essential sources of funds for enterprises.Since bank loan was difficult to attain during financial crisis,according to Alternative Financing Theory,companies would increase the level of trade credit,and the harder the obtainment of bank loan,the higher the net trade credit.Ironically,it is a tendency that resources float to better equipped and better performed companies.Those non-state-owned companies with weaker market power and poorer financial conditions could hardly utilize trade credit.That means,we would get the conclusion that the alternative relationship between bank loan and trade credit is weakened during financial crisis.All in all,trade credit which implies a redistribution of the supply chain is equilibrium under the combined action of supply and demand.The financing support during financial crisis trade credit could provide was rather temporary than permanent.This research has an important guiding significance in business practice.For example,it is wise of enterprises to increase monetary fund holdings and raise the proportion of liquid assets during the financial crisis.