Comparison of Ability and Characteristics of Bactec FX and Bact/Alert 3D Blood Culture Systems in Detection of Bacteremia

Ying Wang,Shi Lining,Ming Fan,Huang Mei,Weiping Wang,Xi Haiyan,Yuan Hu,Jianhua Xuan,Haifeng Shao

2012-01-01

Abstract:Objective To compare the capabilities and characteristics of Bactec FX resin blood culture system Bactec Plus aerobic bottles(referred to as BO-P bottle) and the Bact/Alert 3D automated blood culture system SA standard bottles(referred to as Bio-SA bottle)/SN anaerobic bottle(referred to as Bio-SN bottle) in the detection of bacteremia and study the practical methods for improving the positive rate of blood culture and etiology diagnosis.Methods The venous blood were taken from different parts of each patient,then was injected to BO-P bottle,Bio-SA and Bio-SN bottles respectively,and were cultured by the corresponding culture systems.The results of positive rate and detection time of the three blood culture bottles were compared.Results The meaningful 765 specimens was positive(12.36%) in 6188 specimens,and 134 were confirmed as polluted,accounting for 2.17%.Eleven specimens was false positive,accounting for 0.18%.By using BO-P bottle 293 cases in 332 clinical isolates were detectable,accounting for 88.25%,by using Bio-SA bottles 271 cases were detectable,accounting for 81.63%,by using Bio-SN bottles 201 cases were detectable,accounting for 60.54%,including 3 cases of anaerobic bacteria,accounting for 0.9%.The positive rate(P0.05) and detection time(P0.05) of BO-P bottle were significantly better than Bio-SA bottle,especially for non-fermented bacteria.Gram-positive bacteria(89.55%) was the main bacterial contamination,especially coagulase-negative staphylococci(67.91%),but there were also gram-negative bacteria(9.7%).Conclusion The blood specimen should be collected from bilateral arms.The advantages of Bactec FX blood culture system and Bact/Alert 3D automated blood culture systems should be combined and performed simultaneously.In this way the diagnosis of bloodstream infections may be effectively improved.