Legitimacy Debates and Identity Crisis——In the Case of "aphasia" in Chinese Modern Literary Theory and "westernization" of Chinese Modern Poetry

Xian Zhou
2006-01-01
Abstract:Legitimization is a key notion in the sociological theories of Max Weber, who initiated the concept in the discourses of cultural theories and the analyses of their debates, thus helpful in making clear the cultural significance of the discourses and the debates. Some recent discourses of Chinese modern literary theories and of Chinese modern poetry are worthy of our examination. Both Aphasia in Chinese modern literary theory and Westernization of Chinese modern poetry are virtually challenges to the legitimacy of Chinese modern culture and literature, for they seem to be greatly westernized and deviate from their tradition. These discourses are expressions of an anxiety in cultural identity, which is inevitable in a thorough transformation from traditional culture to modern one. By means of analyzing the relations between re-traditionalization and ontological security, the author tries to make clear a complicated relation between back-to-tradition and contemporary construction of Chinese cultural identity, critically reflects on the misunderstanding of cultural identity and claims that identity on the basis of multi-cultural values is always open to changes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?