Abstract:In the discussion below, I consider the interpretive possibilities of a conceptualization of Chinese socialism that is primarily deconstructive in intention, although it may also provide an occasion for a new reading of the meaning of socialism in our day. My immediate goal is to find a way out of the conceptual prison into which Chinese socialism is forced by ideological efforts to constrict it between received notions of capitalism and socialism. Chinese society today is the subject of radical transformation, which is expressed at the level of ideology by an intense struggle between two discourses that seek to appropriate its future for two alternative visions of history. These discourses, I will argue here, are both irredeemably ideological or, viewed from an alternative perspective, utopian. Chinese socialism justifies itself in terms of a historical vision that has no apparent relevance to the present. This renders it vulnerable to negation at the hands of a discourse embedded in the history of capitalism that strives to colonize the future for its own historical vision. In the process both discourses impose upon the insistently ambiguous evidence of contemporary Chinese socialism interpretive readings that may be sustained only by ignoring evidence contrary to their historical presumptions. Stated bluntly, any representation of China's present historical path as capitalist is not just descriptive but also prescriptive: in other words, such representation is intended to shape the reality that it innocently pretends to describe. The counterinsistence that China is a socialist society headed for communism, on the other hand, uses theoretical conventions to cover up a social situation that distorts socialism out of recognizable form. In his illuminating study, Class Conflict in Chinese Socialism, Richard Kraus has observed that “class analysis . . . is an aspect of the class conflict it is intended to comprehend.” Much the same may be said of the question of socialism in China, which in the affirmation or negation of the relevance to China's future of a socialist vision is part of an ongoing struggle over the future of socialism in Chinese society— and, by extension, globally—in which the major casualty is the concept of socialism itself. The conceptualization I offer here is necessitated by a recognition that to represent presentday Chinese socialism in terms of one or the other of these categories is inevitably to become party to ideological activity that suppresses the most fundamental problems presented to existing ideas of socialism and capitalism by the momentous changes in Chinese society.

Comments on the View of “the Initial Period of Socialism Belonging to Transition Period”

Consequence from Confusing "Transition Period" and "First Stage of Communism"

Exploring on Historical Logic and Theoretical Logic of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics

Postsocialism? Reflections on “socialism with Chinese characteristics”

Retrospect and Prospect: Development of China’s Economics in the Past 70 Years

«DATONGISM» AS THE SOURCE OF «SOCIALISM WITH CHINESE CHARACTERISTICS» (SOME TOPICAL ASPECTS OF KANG YOUWEI'S POLITICAL THEORY)

The Value of Application of Marx' Theory of Socialism

On the Theoretical Features of the Political Economy of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics and the New Issues

On the Concept of Socialization of Production and Innovation of Socialism

Marxist transition theory and its contemporary value——Reconsideration from the general perspective of political economics

The development of "socialism with chinese specifics in a new era": to the results of the XX congress of the communist party of China

Chinese Socialism 3.0:Chongqing Experience

20 Years after Eastern Europe's Radical Change:Review and Reflection

CPC's Understanding about the Socialism in the Sino-Soviet Debate

Where does the socialism with China's characteristics reflect its features

The modernization of socialism with Chinese characteristics:Academic origins,practical explorations and theoretical reflections

Economic Explanation of Accelerated Transition from New Democracy to Socialism

The Essential Feature of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics and Its Effectiveness

The “Sinification” of Marxism: rudiments, a historical parenthesis and a “new round” of development in modern China

On the organic combination of public ownership and market economy

The Materialistic Foundation of Basic Route of "one Center, Two Basic Points"