Abstract:This paper provides a non-traditional review of recent research on the fair value (FV) measurement hierarchy. We begin with a meta-analysis that synthesizes the studies on the value relevance of the FV hierarchy. Overall, we find that the value relevance is lower for level 3 than for levels 1 and 2. We also find that the value relevance of the FV hierarchy has increased over time, particularly for levels 1 and 2: this could be related to a learning effect among key parties (e.g., auditors, managers) and to advancements in technology. As for the level 3 results, the fundamentals of the underlying assets, model risk, and difficulties in conveying the complexity of the measurement process may contribute to a value relevance gap. In addition, we discuss studies that examine other issues related to the FV hierarchy, such as the attributes of investment securities and markets, managerial discretion, information content, and auditing and enforcement. We then evaluate the conclusions reached in the academic literature by adding insights from interviews with auditors and financial reporting professionals from financial institutions. Learning about fair value accounting (FVA) has accumulated over time, bringing a formalization of the FV measurement and reporting process in practice that the academic literature has yet to fully recognize. This highlights conceptual and methodological issues in the existing literature as well as interesting areas for research with practical implications.

Can Board Independence Influence the Value Relevance of Fair Value Measurements

Board Gender Diversity and Cost of Equity: Evidence from Mandatory Female Board Representation

Can Fair Value Measurement Improve the Value Relevance of Quarterly Accounting Earnings——Evidence from Listed Companies in Banking,Insurance,Building & Real Estate Sectors

An Research on Relevance of Financial Instruments'Fair Value Measurement of Real Estate Companies

Fair Value Measurement, Value Relevance and Economic Development: Adoption Evidence of China’s Listed Firms

The Influence of Fair Value Measurement on Radical Financing of Irrational Managers Based on Fixed Effects Model and Fisher Permutation Test

The Relevance of the Fair Value Measurement Hierarchy: A Holistic Perspective

The Influence of Fair Value Measurement on the Pledge of Overconfident Major Shareholders Based on Multiple Regression and Fisher Test.

Board Independence, Ownership Concentration and Corporate Performance - Chinese Evidence

Effect of Independence of the Board on Accounting Conservatism

Discussion of “Value-Relevance of Earnings and Book Value over the Institutional Transition in China: the Suitability of Fair Value Accounting in This Merging Market”

Research on Fair Value Measurement Attribute Application on the Current Economic Conditions

Board hierarchy, independent directors, and firm value: Evidence from China

Relationship Between Board Structure and Firm Value——Based on the Competence Perspective

The Effect of the New Accounting Standards on Value Relevance of Accounting Information

The Effect of Internal Control Deficiencies on the Value Relevance of Accounting Information——an empirical study about Chinese security market

Institutional Investors, Fair Value and Market Volatility: Empirical Evidence from the Panel Data of A-share Stock Market in China

Research on the Value Relevance of Asset Structure for Financially Distressed Listed Companies on China Security Market

The Independence of Independent Directors:Evidence from Board Voting Behavior

Impact of Independent Director's Background on the Firm's Value:Based on the Medium and Small-sized Enterprises Board in China

Fair Value Accounting and Market Volatility