Media Pessimism and Stock Returns: a Time-Varying Analysis at the Firm Level

Khurshid Ahmad,Elaine Hutson,Colm Kearney,Sha Li

2014-01-01

Abstract:The literature on textual analysis of media articles shows that at the aggregate level, negative sentiment leads to a reduction in next-day stock market returns. In the first time-series study of media-expressed sentiment at the firm level, we extract a negative sentiment measure from over five million news articles for the 20 largest nonfinancial US firms over the 10-year period from January 2001 to December 2010. When the firm-level data are aggregated, we find that, consistent with prior studies at the market level, an increase in negative media sentiment (or media pessimism) leads to lower next-day returns. In contrast to prior research, however, we show that this is not reversed over the subsequent few days. This suggests that at the firm level, media pessimism can have permanent effects and can therefore potentially contain information relating to fundamental firm value. When we conduct vector autoregressions on each firm individually over the full 10-year period, this permanent effect is observed in only a few firms. Using a series of rolling regressions, we show that this is because the relation is episodic in nature. These episodes are dominated by periods during which the effects of media pessimism are transitory, but most firms experience at least one period during which media pessimism has permanent effects.