On the Origin Doctrine of Individual Essence

Zhang Li-feng
2010-01-01
Abstract:Kripke made use of the doctrine of origin to support his theory of rigid designator,and McGinn proposed a more sufficient philosophical argument for the doctrine of origin.But the consequences of the doctrine of origin's applications in abiotic things are too rigor for people to accept,while McGinn's essentialism argument either has a false premise or is trivial.For all that,a reductio ad absurdum guarantees that origins satisfy the necessary conditions of being individual essence,but it is evident that origins don't satisfy the sufficient conditions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?