Abstract:Objective: Most emotion perception assessments were developed in western societies using English terms and Caucasian faces, so the extent to which they are cross-culturally valid is in question. To sort this, understanding the mechanisms of cultural variations is the key. In the past half-century, cross-cultural differences in perceiving facial emotions have been consistently reported and discussed, advancing knowledge to feed theoretical and practical interests. However, as these studies are heterogeneous in the questions asked and methods used, without understanding their association, we cannot provide a clear answer to the simple question: why do people from different cultures perceive facial emotions differently? This limitation represents a bottleneck for adapting western clinical assessments cross-culturally to suit the increasing trend of globalisation in research and testing. To address this issue, we conducted a systematic review aiming to reveal the effect of culture on emotion perception from past cross-cultural studies on healthy people. We expected this review to bridge findings in basic research and clinical application. Participants and Methods: The systematic review followed the framework outlined in Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). We searched five databases using three groups of keywords. We included all peer-reviewed original studies that 1) conducted cross-cultural comparison in facial emotion perception with healthy adults and 2) used a design that allowed identifying specific mechanisms to explain cultural variations. The qualitative data synthesis included three steps: 1) categorising eligible studies according to the type of cross-cultural differences they investigated, 2) summarising the findings of each cluster, and 3) summarising the mechanisms revealed by the findings. Results: We found the 122 eligible articles clustered into five groups that investigated 1) how race and in-group and out-group status affected facial emotion perception; 2) cultural differences in using context to identify facial expressions; 3) cultural differences in emotion conceptualisation and how they affected facial emotion perception; 4) cultural differences in interpreting facial muscle configurations; 5) how culture interacted with the inference making process. Seven mechanisms underlying cultural variations in facial emotion perception were revealed. These are facial emotion templates, emotion conceptualisation, in/out-group differentiation, information surveying strategies, belief that expressers are independent agents, reliance on the face and other emotion expressing channels, and stereotypes. The relative importance of these factors may depend on the cultures chosen to compare and the situational settings that affect how they work together in real life. Conclusions: This review, for the first time, systematically addresses the mechanisms underlying cross-cultural differences in facial emotion perception. Besides advancing knowledge about this rapidly growing area, it guides what needs to be considered when designing new tests, adapting existing tests, and assessing the risk of bias brought about by cross-cultural issues.

Culturally diverse facial expression signals diminish the precision of emotion communication across cultures

Facial expressions dynamically cascade emotion category and intensity information over time

How Facial Cues of Models Affect Attention to Websites in Asian and American Cultures

Cultural facial expressions dynamically convey emotion category and intensity information

Facial expressions elicit multiplexed perceptions of emotion categories and dimensions

Deep learning reveals what facial expressions mean to people in different cultures

Smile through your fear and sadness: transmitting and identifying facial expression signals over a range of viewing distances

Emotional Expressions Reconsidered: Challenges to Inferring Emotion From Human Facial Movements

Cultural Differences in Vocal Expression Analysis: Effects of Task, Language, and Stimulus-Related Factors.

The Influence of Cultural Background Information on Emotional Body Language Recognition

Cross-Cultural and Cultural-Specific Production and Perception of Facial Expressions of Emotion in the Wild

6 Why Do Cultures Affect Facial Emotion Perception? - A Systematic Review

The Patterning of Facial Expressions in Chinese, Japanese, and American Infants in Fear- and Anger-Eliciting Situations

How emotion is experienced and expressed in multiple cultures: a large-scale experiment across North America, Europe, and Japan

Recognizing facial expressions of emotion amid noise: A dynamic advantage

Unattended Emotional Prosody Affects Visual Processing of Facial Expressions in Mandarin-Speaking Chinese: A Comparison With English-Speaking Canadians

Beyond Facial Expression: Spatial Distance as a Factor in the Communication of Discrete Emotions

Language access differentially alters functional connectivity during emotion perception across cultures

Cross-cultural patterns in emotion recognition: highlighting design and analytical techniques

Saving Face in Front of the Computer? Culture and Attributions of Human Likeness Influence Users' Experience of Automatic Facial Emotion Recognition

Spatiotemporal structure and substates in facial expressions and speech movements