Abstract:Clouds play a critical role in the climate system by modifying incoming and outgoing radiation. In turn, clouds are affected by climatic changes. Cloud fraction (CF, the part of the sky covered by clouds) is one of the most reliable observed cloud properties and can be regarded as a good first approximation for cloud radiative effects.Different types of clouds modify the energy budget and respond to climatic changes differently. Current climate models predict a negative trend in CF of shallow clouds (with low top height), which will further warm the climate by reducing the reflection of solar radiation. For other types of clouds, the predicted trend in CF has a net-zero radiative effect. The modeled results suffer from large variability and it contributes greatly to the uncertainty of climate projections. Therefore, observational constraints are badly needed.Here, we divide the cloud records into three classes: total clouds (including all clouds), shallow clouds (with top pressure > 700 hPa), and free-atmosphere clouds (other than shallow). For each class, we decompose the general CF into two parts: one which is related to clouds’ horizontal size (CF under cloudy conditions) and a second part, related to the frequency of occurrence (the ratio of cloudy days to all days). 17 years (2003-2019) of satellite observations (MODIS aboard Aqua) and reanalysis data (ERA5) are used in this work. Satellite records show significant regional CF trends. They show that: (1) the trend in shallow clouds’ size dominates the trend in total CF, (2) there are opposite trends between the shallow and free-atmosphere clouds’ occurrence, and (3) the trend in shallow clouds’ occurrence compensate the trend in shallow clouds’ size and lead to a weak trend in shallow CF. It can indicate the development of shallow clouds into free-atmosphere clouds and it can relate to an overlapping problem, where MODIS cannot detect shallow clouds under other clouds. Reanalysis data reveals that after considering a correction for the overlapping problem of cloudy layers, the observed opposite trends (point no. 2 above) are still detected, but to a smaller extent, indicating that this relationship in MODIS records is impacted by the clouds overlapping problem. This means that when considering a correction for the overlapping problem, larger local trends in shallow clouds’ CF (point no. 3 above) are expected. Our findings provide new statistical relationships between clouds’ trends by high-quality observational records and shows that the overlapping problem biases systemically the trends in cloud properties.

Comment on Acp-2022-817

Opposing trends of cloud coverage over land and ocean under global warming

Response and Feedback of Cloud Diurnal Cycle to Rising Temperatures

An Intercomparison of the Spatiotemporal Variability of Satellite- and Ground-Based Cloud Datasets Using Spectral Analysis Techniques

Observed Relationships Between Cloud Fraction Trends of Shallow and Free-atmosphere Clouds

Analyzing Global Trends of Different Cloud Types and Their Potential Impacts on Climate by Using the ISCCP D2 Dataset

Observed Decreasing Trend in the Upper-Tropospheric Cloud Top Temperature

Observational Assessment of Changes in Earth's Energy Imbalance Since 2000

A Study of the Distribution and Variability of Cloud Water Using ISCCP, SSM/I Cloud Product, and Reanalysis Datasets

Contributions From Cloud Morphological Changes to the Interannual Shortwave Cloud Feedback Based on MODIS and ISCCP Satellite Observations

Increasing cloud water resource in a warming world

Analysis and quantification of ENSO-linked changes in the tropical Atlantic cloud vertical distribution using 14 years of MODIS observations

Seasonal and Interannual Characteristics of Atmospheric Cloud Radiative Effect over South China and Neighbouring Ocean Regions

Synergetic Satellite Trend Analysis of Aerosol and Warm Cloud Properties Ver Ocean and Its Implication for Aerosol‐Cloud Interactions

Impact of A Cloud Thermodynamic Phase Parameterization Based on Calipso Observations on Climate Simulation

Using Climate Model Simulations to Constrain Observations

Supplementary Material to "opposing Trends of Cloud Coverage over Land and Ocean under Global Warming"

Examining Cloud Vertical Structure and Radiative Effects from Satellite Retrievals and Evaluation of CMIP6 Scenarios

Evaluation of Stratocumulus Evolution Under Contrasting Temperature Advections in CESM2 Through a Lagrangian Framework

Response of Tropical Overshooting Deep Convection to Global Warming Based on Global Cloud‐Resolving Model Simulations

Analysis of Global Cloud Amount over the Past 30 Years Based on CFSR Data