Climate network percolation reveals the expansion and weakening of the tropical component under global warming

Jingfang Fan,Jun Meng,Yosef Ashkenazy,Shlomo Havlin,Hans Joachim Schellnhuber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1811068115

2018-07-04

Abstract:Global climate warming poses a significant challenge to humanity; it is associated with, e.g., rising sea level and declining Arctic sea ice. Increasing extreme events are also considered to be a result of climate warming~\cite{pachauri2014climate,ogorman_contrasting_2014} and they may have widespread and diverse effects on health, agriculture, economics and political conflicts \cite{hsiang2011civil,helbing_globally_2013,schleussner_armed-conflict_2016,carleton_social_2016}. Still, the detection and quantification of climate change, both in observations and climate models, constitute a main focus of the scientific community. Here we develop a new approach based on network and percolation frameworks \cite{cohen2010complex} to study the impacts of climate changes in the past decades using historical models and reanalysis records, and we analyze the expected upcoming impacts using various future global warming scenarios. More specifically, we classify the globe area into evolving percolation clusters and find a discontinuous phase transition, which indicates a consistent poleward expansion of the largest (tropical) cluster, as well as the weakening of the link's strength. This is found both in the reanalysis data and in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5) twenty-first century climate change simulations~\cite{taylor2012overview}. The analysis is based on high resolution surface (2~m) air temperature field records. We discuss the underlying mechanism for the observed expansion of the tropical cluster and associate it with changes in atmospheric circulation represented by the weakening and expansion of the Hadley cell. Our framework can also be useful for forecasting the extent of the tropical cluster in order to detect its influence on different areas in response to global warming.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact of global warming on the climate system, especially the expansion and weakening phenomena in the tropical region. Specifically, through the network and percolation theory framework, the researchers analyzed the climate data of the past few decades and the climate model predictions under future global warming scenarios to explore how global warming affects the dynamic structure of the tropical region. The main objectives of the study include:

1. **Identifying changes in the tropical region**: By constructing a climate network, the researchers found that while the largest (tropical) cluster is expanding towards the poles, its link strength is also weakening. This finding has been verified in both the re - analysis data and the 21st - century climate change simulations of CMIP5 (Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5).

2. **Relating changes in atmospheric circulation**: The researchers further explored the relationship between these changes and the atmospheric circulation, especially the expansion and weakening of the Hadley Cell. They believe that these changes in the Hadley Cell may be one of the reasons for the expansion and weakening of the tropical region.

3. **Predicting future impacts**: Based on the above analysis, the researchers also explored the potential impacts of the dynamic changes in the tropical region on different regions under future global warming scenarios. This helps to predict and understand the potential impacts of global warming on the climate system.

### Formula summary

- **Temperature difference**:
\[
T_i(t)=\tilde{T}_i(t + 1)-\tilde{T}_i(t)
\]

- **Time - delayed cross - correlation function**:
\[
C_{i,j}(\tau)=\frac{\langle T_i(t)T_j(t+\tau)\rangle-\langle T_i(t)\rangle\langle T_j(t+\tau)\rangle}{\sqrt{\langle(T_i(t)-\langle T_i(t)\rangle)^2\rangle}\cdot\sqrt{\langle(T_j(t+\tau)-\langle T_j(t+\tau)\rangle)^2\rangle}}
\]
\[
C_{i,j}(-\tau)=C_{j,i}(\tau)
\]

- **Link strength**:
\[
W_{i,j}=\frac{\max(|C_{i,j}(\tau)|)-\text{mean}(C_{i,j}(\tau))}{\text{std}(C_{i,j}(\tau))}
\]

- **Relative size of the largest cluster**:
\[
G_1=\frac{\max\left[\sum_{i\in S_1}\cos(\phi_i),\cdots,\sum_{i\in S_m}\cos(\phi_i),\cdots\right]}{\sum_{i = 1}^N\cos(\phi_i)}
\]

- **Slope of the trend line**:
\[
W_c(t)=a+\xi_W\ast t
\]
\[
G_c(t)=b+\xi_G\ast t
\]

- **Hadley Cell intensity**:
\[
\bar{V}=\frac{g}{2\pi R\cos(\phi)}\frac{\partial\Psi}{\partial p}
\]

where \(\bar{V}\) is the zonally - averaged meridional wind speed, \(R\) is the average radius of the earth, \(p\) is the air pressure, and \(\Psi\) is the stream function.

Through these methods and formulas, the researchers have successfully revealed the dynamic changes in the tropical region under the background of global warming and their impacts on the climate system.