Observation of an Anomalous Line Shape of Theη′π+π−mass Spectrum Near The

M. Ablikim,M. N. Achasov,S. Ahmed,Xiaocong Ai,O. Albayrak,M. Albrecht,D. J. Ambrose,A. Amoroso,F. F. An,Q. An,J. Z. Bai,R. Baldini Ferroli,Y. Ban,D. W. Bennett,J. V. Bennett,N. Berger,M. Bertani,D. Bettoni,J. M. Bian,F. Bianchi,E. Boger,I. Boyko,R.A. Briere,H. Cai,X. Cai,O. Çakır,A. Calcaterra,G. F. Cao,S. A. Cetin,J. F. Chang,G. Chelkov,G. Chen,H. S. Chen,H. Y. Chen,J. C. Chen,M. L. Chen,S Chen,S. J. Chen,X Chen,X. R. Chen,Y. B. Chen,H. P. Cheng,X. Chu,G. Cibinetto,H. L. Dai,J. P. Dai,A. Dbeyssi,D. Dedovich,Zhi Deng,A. Denig,I. Denysenko,M. Destefanis,F. De Mori,Y. Ding,C. Dong,J. Dong,L. Y. Dong,M. Y. Dong,Z. L. Dou,S. X. Du,Pengfei Duan,Jingzhou Fan,J. Fang,Fang Su,X. Fang,Y. Fang,R. Farinelli,L. Fava,Oleg Fedorov,F. Feldbauer,G. Felici,C. Q. Feng,E. Fioravanti,M. Fritsch,C. D. Fu,Q. Gao,X. L. Gao,X. Y. Gao,Y. Gao,Z. Gao,I. Garzia,K. Goetzen,L. Gong,W. X. Gong,W. Gradl,M. Greco,M. H. Gu,Y. T. Gu,Y. H. Guan,A. Q. Guo,L. B. Guo,R. P. Guo,Y. P. Guo,Z. Haddadi,A. Hafner,Shuo Han,X. Q. Hao,F. A. Harris,K. L. He,F. H. Heinsius,T. Held,Yang Heng,T. Holtmann,Z. L. Hou,Hu Chen,H. M. Hu,Jifeng Hu,T. Hu,Y. Hu,G. S. Huang,Y. Huang,J. S. Huang,X. Huang,X. Z. Huang,Z. Huang,T. Hussain,Q. P. Ji,X. B. Ji,X. L. Ji,L. W. Jiang,Xiaojie Jiang,X. Y. Jiang,J. B. Jiao,Z. Jiao,D. P. Jin,S. Jin,T. Johansson,A. Julin,N. Kalantar–Nayestanaki,X. L. Kang,X. S. Kang,M. Kavatsyuk,B. C. Ke,P. Kiese,R. Kliemt,B. Kloss,O. B. Kolcu,B. Kopf,M. Kornicer,A. Kupść,W. Kühn,Johannes Lange,M. Lara,P. Larin,H. Leithoff,C. Leng,C. Li,Cheng Li,D. M. Li,F. Li,F. Y. Li,G. Li,H. B. Li,H. J. Li,J. C. Li,Jin Li,K Li,K. Li,Lei Li,P. R. Li,Q. Y. Li,T. Li,W. D. Li,W. G. Li,X. L. Li,X. N. Li,X. Q. Li,Y. B. Li,Z. B. Li,H. Liang,Y. F. Liang,Y. T. Liang,G. R. Liao,D. X. Lin,B. Liu,B. J. Liu,C. X. Liu,D. Liu,F. H. Liu,Fang Liu,Feng Liu,H. B. Liu,H. H. Liu,H. M. Liu,J. Liu,J. B. Liu,J. P. Liu,J. Y. Liu,K. Liu,K. Y. Liu,L. D. Liu,P. L. Liu,Q. Liu,S. B. Liu,X. Liu,Y. B. Liu,Y. Y. Liu,Z. A. Liu,Zhiqing Liu,H. Loehner,Xuanhong Lou,H. J. Lü,J. G. Lu,Y. P. Lu,C. L. Luo,M. X. Luo,T. Luo,X. L. Luo,Xiao-Rui Lyu,F. C.,H. L.,L. L.,M. M.,Q. M.,T. Ma,X. N.,X. Y.,Y. M.,F. E. Maas,M. Maggiora,Q. A. Malik,Y. J. Mao,Z. P. Mao,S. Marcello,J. G. Messchendorp,G. Mezzadri,J. Min,T. J. Min,Robin E. Mitchell,X. H. Mo,Y. J. Mo,Morales,N. Yu. Muchnoi,H. Muramatsu,P. Musiol,Y. Nefedov,F. Nerling,I. B. Nikolaev,Z. Ning,S. Nisar,S. L. Niu,X. Y. Niu,S. L. Olsen,Q. Ouyang,S. Pacetti,Y. Pan,P. Patteri,M. Pelizaeus,H. P. Peng,K. Peters,J. Pettersson,J. L. Ping,R. G. Ping,R. Poling,V. Prasad,H. R. Qi,M. Qi,S. Qian,C. F. Qiao,L. Q. Qin,N. Qin,X. S. Qin,Z. H. Qin,J. F. Qiu,K. H. Rashid,C. F. Redmer,M. Ripka,G. Rong,Ch. Rosner,Xifeng Ruan,A. Sarantsev,M. Savrié,C. Schnier,K. Schoenning,Svenja Schumann,W. Shan,M. Shao,C. P. Shen,P. X. Shen,X. Y. Shen,H. Y. Sheng,Mengyao Shi,W. M. Song,X. Y. Song,S. Sosio,S. Spataro,G. X. Sun,J. F. Sun,S. S. Sun,X. H. Sun,Y. J. Sun,Y. Z. Sun,Zhi‐Wei Sun,Z. T. Sun,C. J. Tang,X. Tang,İ. Tapan,E. H. Thorndike,M. Tiemens,I. Uman,G. Varner,B. Wang,B. L. Wang,D. Wang,D. Y. Wang,K. Wang,L. L. Wang,L. S. Wang,M. Wang,P. Wang,P. L. Wang,S. G. Wang,W. Wang,W. P. Wang,X. F. Wang,Y. Wang,Y. D. Wang,Y. F. Wang,Y. Q. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. G. Wang,Z. H. Wang,Z. Y. Wang,T. Weber,D. H. Wei,J. B. Wei,P. C. Weidenkaff,S. P. Wen,U. Wiedner,M. Wolke,L. H. Wu,L. J. Wu,Z. Wu,Ligang Xia,Y. Xia,D. Xiao,H. Xiao,Z. J. Xiao,Y. Xie,Q. L. Xiu,G. F. Xu,Jingjing Xu,Xu Li,Q. J. Xu,Qing Xu,X. P. Xu,L. Yan,W. B. Yan,W. C. Yan,Y. H. Yan,H. J. Yang,H. X. Yang,L. Yang,Y. X. Yang,M. Ye,M. H. Ye,J. H. Yin,B. X. Yu,C. X. Yu,Jie Yu,C. Z. Yuan,W. L. Yuan,Y. Yuan,A. Yuncu,A. A. Zafar,A. Zallo,Y. Zeng,Z. Zeng,B. X. Zhang,B. Y. Zhang,C. Zhang,C. C. Zhang,D. H. Zhang,H. H. Zhang,H. Y. Zhang,J. Zhang,J. J. Zhang,J. L. Zhang,J. Q. Zhang,J. W. Zhang,J. Y. Zhang,J. Z. Zhang,K. Zhang,L. Zhang,S. Q. Zhang,X. Y. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. H. Zhang,Y. N. Zhang,Y. T. Zhang,Yu Zhang,Z. H. Zhang,Z. P. Zhang,Z. Y. Zhang,Guoying Zhao,J. W. Zhao,J. Y. Zhao,J. Z. Zhao,Zhao Liu,Ling Zhao,M. G. Zhao,Q. Zhao,Shan Zhao,T. C. Zhao,Y. B. Zhao,Z. G. Zhao,A. Zhemchugov,B. Zheng,J. P. Zheng,W. J. Zheng,Yi Zheng,B. Zhong,L. Zhou,X. Y. Zhou,X. K. Zhou,X. R. Zhou,K. Zhu,S. H. Zhu,Xiaoyu Zhu,Y. C. Zhu,Y. S. Zhu,Z. A. Zhu,J. Zhuang,L. Zotti,B. S. Zou,J. H. Zou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.117.042002

IF: 8.6

2016-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:Using $1.09\times10^{9}$ $J/\psi$ events collected by the BESIII experiment in 2012, we study the $J/\psi\rightarrow\gamma\eta^{\prime}\pi^{+}\pi^{-}$ process and observe a significant abrupt change in the slope of the $\eta^{\prime}\pi^{+}\pi^{-}$ invariant mass distribution at the proton-antiproton ($p\bar{p}$) mass threshold. We use two models to characterize the $\eta^{\prime}\pi^{+}\pi^{-}$ line shape around $1.85~\text{GeV}/c^{2}$: one which explicitly incorporates the opening of a decay threshold in the mass spectrum (Flatté formula), and another which is the coherent sum of two resonant amplitudes. Both fits show almost equally good agreement with data, and suggest the existence of either a broad state around $1.85~\text{GeV}/c^{2}$ with strong couplings to $p\bar{p}$ final states or a narrow state just below the $p\bar{p}$ mass threshold. Although we cannot distinguish between the fits, either one supports the existence of a $p\bar{p}$ molecule-like state or bound state with greater than $7\sigma$ significance.